Employment recovers strongly in Victoria, but it’s about to lose meaning

This post is 4 years old. The data and my views may have since evolved.

Despite the gloomy headlines about ever increasing unemployment rates in Victoria, the effective unemployment rate continued to drop quickly in June.   Based on my methodology of projecting sector-specific BC employment on to the Victoria labour market, the effective employment rate has halved since April, dropping from an estimate of 18.1% to 9.3% in June.

That’s good news for us and the rapid nature of the recovery in employment so far is what I expected given many of the unemployed were simply forced out due to business shutdowns that have since reopened.  However most of the low hanging fruit has been picked as of the Phase 3 reopening in BC, and the remainder of the unemployed will take longer to return to work.   We won’t be returning to our ultra-low unemployment rate anytime soon.

So far the government has managed to paper over any employment losses with emergency financial supports that solidly exceeded any losses in employment income.   The velocity of all that CERB money is very high since it has been given out primarily to lower income people who have lost their jobs.  That means most of it is likely being spent quite quickly and thus going directly back to the economy to support those jobs that weren’t lost.  In some ways then, the current economy is an illusion.  There is more money floating around than before the pandemic which is giving a sense of normalcy when the reality is anything but.   We’re building a bridge over the gap, but we don’t yet know if we’ll reach the other side before the bridge runs out.

Many people are worried about what happens when the billions in CERB stop flowing.  That will hurt consumer spending, but with some luck the majority of CERB recipients will be back to work before that happens and I assume the rest will transition to EI so their income will decline but not disappear.   An interesting point to note is that there have been 1,105,030 unique CERB applicants in BC, or a staggering 44% of the pre-pandemic number of employed people.   That compares to a peak drop in employment of only 383,000 people.  Of course there is some churn here (some lost their job while others regained it in the past few months), but three times as many people accessing a program for those who lost their jobs than peak job loss seems rather startling.   I wonder if there will be lots of rude surprises come tax time.  In any case it seems the push to transition people from CERB to the business wage subsidy program CEWS can’t come soon enough.   That 75% wage subsidy program for employers is widely expected to be extended past the current deadline of August 29th in some form has just been extended to the end of the year.   However, while it’s certainly better to have people in a productive job than out of work, it’s all still dependent on the flow of money continuing.

With more businesses accessing CEWS to hire back employees, the unemployment rate will certainly go down, but it will lose some meaning as the measure of how well the economy is doing in providing jobs.   If your job exists only because your wage is subsidized 75% and the employer is getting commercial rent relief are you really employed?   Right now the biggest sector accessing CEWS is “Professional, scientific and technical services”, which has not seen mass layoffs, perhaps partially for that reason.   In the end it all needs to be unwound and we won’t know how well we’ve done until that happens.

The same is true of the real estate market.   With June’s promising numbers I cautioned that it’s too early to declare victory for the market.  July and August will be strong months, with sales likely 30-50% higher than last year.   But a big part of what’s happening here is the burning up of pent up demand.  Don’t mistake this for our normal market that you can now extrapolate out to the future.  We will very likely still see some dramatic shifts this year.

Y axis deliberately omitted. Illustration only, not a forecast.

We lost some 800 sales due to the pandemic, and some of those will end up happening in July, August, and September.  That will push sales unnaturally higher in a time when sales usually drop, which means they will look especially good for those late summer months.   But eventually the market will settle down and we’ll see the true level of activity.   That return to normal will coincide very closely with the expiration of CERB, the expiration of most mortgage deferrals, and whatever the re-imagined CEWS looks like.

It would be silly to try to forecast the state of the market in the late fall with all that uncertainty.  I think we can be relatively confident that we will see some more inventory start hitting the market in the fall and into 2021.   Based on the extreme shortage of listings in the detached market right now, I don’t think the extra inventory will be enough to tip that market into territory that would lead to substantial price declines, but it should bring a bit more balance.  As always, the condo market is more vulnerable in downturns.


Also weekly numbers courtesy of the VREB

July 2020
July
2019
Wk 1 Wk 2 Wk 3 Wk 4
Sales 111 329 706
New Listings 201 549 1152
Active Listings 2675 2710 2949
Sales to New Listings 55% 60% 61%
Sales YoY Change 36% 38%
Months of Inventory 4.2

The shift towards detached sales continues, with 1.9 single family homes selling for every condo in the last few weeks.   Last year it was 1.5.   Over ask statistics reflect the same, with a pretty steady 1 in 4 detached properties going over asking price, while only about 1 in 12 condos does.  Inventory is fairly steady, still down about 10% from this time last year.

Both new listings and sales are higher than this time last year, but sales have increased more, which means the market overall is hotter than this time last year as shown by the months of inventory, which crossed over from weaker to stronger around mid June.  That’s a strong sellers market for the detached market at least.  If you were considering selling and were put off by the pandemic, this may be a good time to bring your house to market.

189 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Morrisey
July 20, 2020 1:31 pm

Thanks for the info Leo & Marko.

Gordon C
Gordon C
July 20, 2020 11:44 am

Thinking about renting a home as a single tenancy and not sharing part of the home with someone else*

Allow me to help you to know what you will be getting for your money.

Take what you want to pay annually for rent and divide that by 3.5%. That will give you a rough idea of the value of the house you would get for your money.

If you are willing to pay say $3,200 a month in rent, then that would be equivalent to a house with a value of 38,400/0.035 or $1,100,000 (approximately). Now you can go shopping for houses in the different neighborhoods to see what you can get.

*This doesn’t work for houses with suites or homes with acreage, water views or water frontage. It’s just a rough gauge of what kind of home you can reasonably expect.

Happy house hunting.

Sidekick
Sidekick
July 19, 2020 10:09 pm

They are net zero and use solar to produce their electrical energy.

Looks like they’re actually net positive if you ignore the propane and wood combustion. But if you converted that propane and wood energy to equivalent electricity they’d be pretty far from net zero. They have a 2kW array which isn’t going to cover 6 people producing and processing food on-site.

Which part?

I can’t remember…not sure if I read about it or heard from someone with knowledge of the project. I have a very vague recollection that it was something more substantial than pipe sizing.

My point is that something being ‘permitted’ isn’t much use if the implementation is nearly impossible….and let me tell you that the majority of these types of things are very challenging and/or expensive to implement. There is a good reason a lot of this fun stuff happens outside of the jurisdiction of building codes (gulf islands for example).

I have all kinds of personal examples but I won’t pollute the blog with that.

totoro
totoro
July 19, 2020 8:45 pm

their energy usage numbers are surprisingly high

I don’t really understand the numbers as this is not my area. They are net zero and use solar to produce their electrical energy.

They preface the use with a statement that the three generations living in the home have “the per person electrical energy intensity of the occupants of this home is about 90% less than the average person in BC. Reduction of energy consumption both for operations and for amortized construction carbon footprint has been the primary energy strategy.” Is energy intensity the same as consumption?

Could it be the three cords of wood used annually to which they ascribe a value of 16,705 kWhrs is pushing up the total?
https://ecosenseliving.files.wordpress.com/2010/01/prerequisite-04-net-zero-energy-2.pdf

totoro
totoro
July 19, 2020 8:05 pm

This project had to go all the way to Ottawa to get approved.

Which part? Their grey water system had to get a specific approval due to smaller pipe sizing than normal, but subsurface greywater irrigation and tub to toilet recycling are are permitted now is my understanding?

Marko Juras
July 19, 2020 7:11 pm

Duttons Property Management often has a few listings on their website.

I haven’t searched Facebook marketplace but when I put my units up for rent on Usedvic, Craigslist and Facebook 80% of the inquiries are from Facebook.

Morrisey
July 19, 2020 6:34 pm

Hi folks. My RN partner seems imminently to be offered a transfer to the Victoria area for a senior position, so it looks like we may finally be able to come back to the area.

We’ll be looking to rent, initially – pet friendly, bright ground level with yard access, newer than 1993, away from busy roads. Tall order, I know. UsedVictoria (and Craigslist) seems to be the site(s) to watch, or is there something else we should be minding? Any areas to avoid? We’re looking forward to daily Thetis walks (or anywhere forested away from traffic). Thanks!

Sidekick
Sidekick
July 19, 2020 5:36 pm

You can do a laundry/bath to irrigation system under the code. You can also recycle to toilet. Here is one in the Highlands:
https://living-future.org/lbc/case-studies/eco-sense-residence-victoria/

This project had to go all the way to Ottawa to get approved. While extremely commendable, this is not an example of what your typical homeowner/builder is going to be able to do.

As an aside, the LBC (living building challenge) part is great, but their energy usage numbers are surprisingly high.

Introvert
Introvert
July 19, 2020 5:26 pm

Then when the tide goes out we will learn who has been swimming naked.

Bring it.

When the tide goes out, my extremely high-quality wetsuit will be revealed 🙂

Gordon C
Gordon C
July 19, 2020 4:00 pm

As for using the previous years assessed value.

I use a Sales to Assessment Ratio (SAR) as a cross check to the final conclusion in my appraisals. I can’t use the latest assessments as VREB does not use that for its calculations. Instead I have to present both this year and the previous year assessed values in the reports.

For most properties I am still finding that the previous years median SAR for houses, excluding outliers, is a few percentage points over. Depending on your immediate area the typical home is selling at 105% of its previous years assessed value.

And that puts Victoria’s house prices, depending on where you live, up by some 5 % over last year.

I also work with several groups of investors wanting to purchase properties, renovate, and sell. They of course feel like this is the time to vulch on sellers and throw in low ball offers. That type of strategy isn’t going to work because the market place strongly favors sellers. Furthermore, there are not that many duress listings as the banks are not foreclosing on home owners. These investors have a lot of cash and really want to spend it.

The way I try to explain this market to them is that while this is a sellers market you don’t have to let your enthusiasm get in the way of making an informed decision. Slow down and crunch the numbers first. If it’s not this property there will always be another coming onto the market later. In the words of Ford Prefect “DON’T PANIC”

In my opinion, I doubt we will see any change until the fourth quarter or 1st quarter of 2021 when (if) these stimulus packages end.

Then when the tide goes out we will learn who has been swimming naked.

Barrister
Barrister
July 19, 2020 3:14 pm

Raw human manure is used for the production and growth of real estate agents. Back to the housing market.

totoro
totoro
July 19, 2020 2:59 pm

Raw animal manure is OMRI approved!

Non-organic farmers have no time limit between application and harvest. Certified organic farmers are prohibited from spreading fresh manure for at least 90 days before harvesting crops intended for human consumption. For crops that come in direct contact with the soil, the minimum time period is 120 days.

Fresh produce is the cause of most food borne illnesses in NA.

Barrister
Barrister
July 19, 2020 2:26 pm

LeoS: Interesting to see the build up of inventory but what is the breakdown of SFH vs condos.

Mt. Tolmie Foothills
Mt. Tolmie Foothills
July 19, 2020 1:14 pm

In depth composting discussions?

Yeah, I wasn’t looking for a debate, but you never know what will happen in this forum!

Non-organic commercial farmers do use uncomposted animal manure and it does pose a health risk and can result in recalls of affected produce.

Raw animal manure is OMRI approved! (With some precautions.) My apologies if that upsets anyone who thought they were clean by eating only organic produce.

LookingAtOptions
LookingAtOptions
July 19, 2020 12:57 pm

Sorry Leo, not blaming you. Indeed you have mentioned you were not impressed, in your previous comments. I just read your “test of competency” comment as leaning towards being dismissive.

I’ll believe the switchover when I see it.

Still, the damage has been done. A qualified journalist needs to survey what the direct extent of that damage was to directly affected buyers (nevermind the cascading effect that purchase price subsequently has on other home.purchases), and make it public.

patriotz
patriotz
July 19, 2020 12:53 pm

because their Realtor who stands to get a commission of many thousands of dollars is misrepresenting the value of the home?

The value of the home is the highest price that someone is willing to pay for it today. An assessment is a guess of the highest price that someone would have been willing to pay for it at some point in the past. It’s not a hard fact like the size of the property, which realtors often get wrong and don’t guarantee to be correct.

LookingAtOptions
LookingAtOptions
July 19, 2020 12:29 pm

“Think of it as a free way to see who is competent.”

Same with any of the many fraudulent phone scams, or email scams. Many can be very convincing. Is that how we should think of those, too? Some of those can even be very crafty about how they word things, such that technically they don’t even out-and-out lie.

At least with phone or email scams, we know the person contacting us is a complete stranger. Realtors and their listing information are extremely well subsidized by commissions, and furthermore have a monopoly on sales data and a near-monopoly on transactions. All this deserves much more than a shoulder shrug.

Should out-of-province retirees, many whom can hardly get around MS Windows or email, be expected to know that they should go to the BC Assessment website because their Realtor who stands to get a commission of many thousands of dollars is misrepresenting the value of the home?

Your comment reminds me of a news story i saw on Thailand once, and how some of the deeply religious Buddhist locals there won’t think twice about ripping off or defrauding foreigners. They generally squared the two opposing viewpoints by saying what amounts to, “If they are too stupid to know they are being ripped off, Buddism principles have no problem with it”

LookingAtOptions
LookingAtOptions
July 19, 2020 12:16 pm

PS – I’ve even RECENTLY overheard real estate agents talking to each other, referring to the incorrect (older) assessed value as if it is the correct one.

Realtor A: “My client (buyer) might be willing to offer a price down closer to assessed value”

Realtor B: “Go for it. I think my client (seller) would be willing to seriously look at an offer around that range”.

Realtor A: “Wait, you know I’m talking about the actual most recent assessed value, not the older one listed,right?”

Realtor B: “What??! No, in that case forget it,.my client wouldn’t consider that”

The point of this isn’t whether or not people should be paying 2019 assessed values right now. The point is, even professional Realtors are referring to the incorrect older values as if they are correct.

You can be sure many of them are not telling their clients what the correct/updated assessed values are, either.

Also, as I have mentioned here before, when open houses were going on earlier this year, printed property details often had the incorrect assessed value listed. And, when I would gently ask the open house about the assessed value, I would often be told the wrong value.

LookingAtOptions
LookingAtOptions
July 19, 2020 11:59 am

“How is this not fraud?”

A journalist interested in a potentially eye-opening consumer fraud story should mail out or leaflet any Victoria homes sold since January, where the wrong assessed value was shown. It should be easy to figure out which homes those were, by looking at the electronic history of sold listings since January 2020.

A letter mailed or dropped off with only those potentially affected purchasers that MIGHT have been affected can read:

“Dear homeowner, congratulations on your recent purchase of your new home. I am a journalist for _______, researching a story on the effects of assessed values being misrepresented to Victoria real estate consumers.

Since January 2020 many older (higher) assessed values have been shown on many Realtor websites and printed matter, advertising properties for sale. In some cases, those incorrect older/higher assessed values were referenced in the property listing descriptions.

Your property is among those for which the older/incorrect assessed value was shown on Realtor websites and printed matter.

Your home’s latest assessment, for July 1, 2019, was actually $________.
The assessed value that has been shown on Realtor listing sites since January 1, 2020 is for a year beforehand, July 1, 2018, for $________.

Can you help me as I compile research for my story? You are FULLY guaranteed to remain anonymous unless you request otherwise.

Q1. Which assessed value did you believe to be the most current, when you made your recent home purchase? A. $_______ B. $______ C. Ofher

Q2. When you were deciding on the purchase of your home, who/what made you aware of what you believed to be the most recent published assessed value? (Choose all that apply). A. Realtor-provided web access to listings. B. Realtor-provided property description sheet. C. Verbal/email discussions with Realtor. D. BC assessment website E. Other (please specify)

Q3. How important was the assessed value which you believed to be most current, to the price you decided to pay for your property? A. Extremely important. B. Somewhat important. C. Not important.

Q4. If you were only aware of the erroneously listed assessed value at the time of purchase, would knowing the true latest published assessed value have changed what you offered to purchase the property?

Feel free to call or email me with any questions, comments, or anecdotes you have on the issue, and when you do please also identify yourself by the address which you recently purchased.

Sincerely,

XYZ newspaper/media/TV”

Next step: Compile results of your survey.
Then, ask the BC real estate consumer rights advocate for comments.
And, ask Victoria real estate board and any other relevant entities for comments.

Write it all up, and you MIGHT just have a good story on your hands!

Something this kind of survey still wouldn’t capture is, how many people’s offers for other properties (for which assessed value was correct/up to date) were affected by other incorrect assessed values they were looking at?

patriotz
patriotz
July 19, 2020 11:52 am

How is this not fraud?

The bar is a lot higher for fraud. That would be selling you something that doesn’t exist, or that the “seller” doesn’t actually own. This is more like those retail sales where the price is marked down from a “regular” price that was jacked up. Something the Competition Bureau might be interested in, but not the police.

totoro
totoro
July 19, 2020 11:31 am

I have a hard time believing you can do this within a municipality. Seems like there is always at least one gotcha with these types of things.

You can do a laundry/bath to irrigation system under the code. You can also recycle to toilet. Here is one in the Highlands:
https://living-future.org/lbc/case-studies/eco-sense-residence-victoria/

Sidekick
Sidekick
July 19, 2020 11:16 am

You can already do this under the Building Code.

I have a hard time believing you can do this within a municipality. Seems like there is always at least one gotcha with these types of things.

Kenny G
Kenny G
July 19, 2020 10:21 am

The first 3 new listing properties that came through my brokers filter today all still using the assessed value from 2018, which just happens to be substantially higher then last years assessment. An example is 3225 Exeter Rd listed at 1.77, using 2018 assessment at 1.72 when last years assessment was 1.55. I guess seller trying to do anything they can to minimize the loss from purchase in 2017 for 1.9 plus LTT, looks like their heading for a loss of at least 200K.

Oh and look at 3.75 Exeter, 2018 assessment 2.23 and 2019 assessment 1.83 listed at 2.46, guess which assessment they are using? How is this not fraud?

totoro
totoro
July 19, 2020 9:30 am

Where the money will be coming from for these three years?

Redevelopment of the property adding value plus any accrued appreciation. After it is fully redeveloped and rented (year three) I don’t see added value. Probably should be sold at that point. Maybe that is their plan.

freedom _2008
freedom _2008
July 19, 2020 9:06 am

they are predicting 14% roi per year for the first three years.

Where the money will be coming from for these three years? From the subsequent investors? Hum …

totoro
totoro
July 19, 2020 8:43 am

Addy is an interesting idea. I’ve thought fractional ownership was the way to go for a long time. I would not be interested in paying others to do this or losing control of the process myself, but we’ll see how they do – they are predicting 14% roi per year for the first three years. The money you could make after that is going to depend on appreciation really as rents will likely go to the 40% financing and management fees. Not sure why someone would stay invested or buy shares after year three. The share value will drop if appreciation stalls or declines – or interest rates rise.

patriotz
patriotz
July 19, 2020 8:40 am

isn’t it just another REIT

REIT’s trade on stock exchanges and so are subject to an array of regulations to protect investors. This appears to be some sort of private investment vehicle with unaccountable management and no guarantee of liquidity and I can see where that’s likely to go. Sounds rather like Wework in its marketing and you know how that turned out.

freedom_2008
freedom_2008
July 19, 2020 8:15 am

WRT Addy, isn’t it just another REIT, but with smaller priced units and is focused in residential properties?

totoro
totoro
July 19, 2020 8:14 am

But I do often wonder why we don’t have separate pipe for toilets outputs from other “used” water (Grey water) in our home plumbing system? Guess that might be added into building code when water shortage issue getting severe …

You can already do this under the Building Code.
https://www2.gov.bc.ca/assets/gov/environment/waste-management/sewage/provincial-composting-toilet-manual.pdf

freedom_2008
freedom_2008
July 19, 2020 7:48 am

In depth composting discussions?

Right, for those who never use raw manure but think dumping our raw sewage in the ocean is to ” enrich the ocean with nutrients and cause an abundance of sea life” 🙂

But I do often wonder why we don’t have separate pipe for toilets outputs from other “used” water (Grey water) in our home plumbing system? Guess that might be added into building code when water shortage issue getting severe …

Chris
Chris
July 19, 2020 7:22 am

In depth composting discussions?

totoro
totoro
July 19, 2020 7:10 am

You shouldn’t use uncomposted manure in a home garden unless it comes from alpacas or rabbits. Everything else needs to be aged unless you want to risk a million weeds, burnt plants and potential pathogen contamination with E. coli, Salmonella, Listeria monocytogenes and Campylobacter.

Non-organic commercial farmers do use uncomposted animal manure and it does pose a health risk and can result in recalls of affected produce. New regulations are under development for this.

As for humanmanure, it can be used on non-edible plants after composting. Grey water systems are pretty easy to retrofit and legal. Probably an easier win in an urban area than composting toilets that need to be emptied.

freedom _2008
freedom _2008
July 18, 2020 10:29 pm

No, I haven’t. It would not be worth the hassle in a home garden.

So you just imagined they are used raw on farms? 😉 .

BTW, we don’t own a farm, but did WOOFER at an organic farm that uses aged manures to fertilize their veg fields. It was really hard and smelly work (also needed to fight with the roosters ).

Mt. Tolmie Foothills
Mt. Tolmie Foothills
July 18, 2020 6:32 pm

Have you tried yourself?

No, I haven’t. It would not be worth the hassle in a home garden.

freedom_2008
freedom_2008
July 18, 2020 6:31 pm

Victoria-bound flight had COVID-19 on board, BCCDC says

Could those visitors be the recent new cases on the island (as the cases are counted by where they are tested)?

freedom_2008
freedom_2008
July 18, 2020 6:25 pm

I mean raw animal manure. Often used in agriculture.

Have you tried to use them yourself? We use steer manure for our garden, but they must be aged (i.e. composted). The fresh raw ones (not aged/composted) are too strong and can burn plants /crops, a common knowledge to gardeners/farmers.

Introvert
Introvert
July 18, 2020 6:09 pm
Mt. Tolmie Foothills
Mt. Tolmie Foothills
July 18, 2020 6:03 pm

You mean composted manure

I mean raw animal manure. Often used in agriculture.

QT
QT
July 18, 2020 5:35 pm

lol, I expect you would be shocked to learn how much of the food you eat was fertilized with raw manure.

Sewage is not comprise of only faeces, but also contains heavy metals, plenols, pharmaceuticals, house hold chemicals/detergents, farm runoff and road runoff pollution.

Mussels on drugs found near Victoria sewage outfalls — https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/sewage-victoria-crd-drugs-contamination-mussels-pharmaceuticals-1.4537222

Sewage sludge — https://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php/Sewage_sludge

Sludge contaminants — https://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php/Sludge_contaminants

patriotz
patriotz
July 18, 2020 3:58 pm

If you click through to the source data, you’ll find that about 10,000 invitations under express entry were issued to US residents in 2019. That’s up proportionally from previous years, but still comprises a small % of total immigration. Doesn’t change my expectation that immigration will be down until there’s a resolution of this pandemic.

James Soper
James Soper
July 18, 2020 3:57 pm

lol, I expect you would be shocked to learn how much of the food you eat was fertilized with raw manure.

You mean composted manure.
You’re talking about night soil, which spreads disease, and a major reason not to put it right into the water that people swim in.

Whale Tales
Whale Tales
July 18, 2020 2:01 pm

Is there anyway we could get a thumbs down button on this site?

Mt. Tolmie Foothills
Mt. Tolmie Foothills
July 18, 2020 12:33 pm

Go ahead and spread it on your vegetable patch and let us know how that works out for you.

lol, I expect you would be shocked to learn how much of the food you eat was fertilized with raw manure.

Patrick
Patrick
July 18, 2020 12:32 am

Structure of the new CEWS with phase out targeted by end of year.

While it’s good they’re phasing it out, why are they paying 10% of wages for companies with small revenue loss like 10%? That could be due to factors other than CoVid, and companies could make those numbers happen with creative accounting . Seems like a stupid giveaway to many companies that don’t need it.

freedom_2008
freedom_2008
July 17, 2020 10:33 pm

Active cases could be misleading (as Alberta has done more tests than any other provinces), but hospital cases are perhaps better representing:

covid hospital cases.jpg
Introvert
Introvert
July 17, 2020 6:55 pm

Was crunching the COVID numbers for B.C. and Alberta, and the differences are quite stunning: we have 4 times fewer active cases and hospitalizations despite having 15% greater population.

And, very worrisomely, half of Alberta’s active cases are “of unknown origin.”

https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/edmonton/alberta-adds-105-new-cases-of-covid-19-and-2-more-deaths-1.5654318

Marko Juras
July 17, 2020 4:09 pm

3237 Service 10 offers and goes for 818k.

rush4life
rush4life
July 17, 2020 3:10 pm

Anna what Leo is saying is – lets assume rents are down from January – say $100 on a one bedroom place. The chances that you rented to someone in January at the peak and now have to re-rent to someone else is much lower than a landlord who was been renting to someone for the last year, two years, 5 years etc. So even if you believe rents have come down some, the majority of the landlords looking for tenants are still going to see an increase in rents as the time they started renting to their tenants the rent prices were much lower and so they may not be getting the max they could have but they will still be getting a substantial increase. Take my place for example. I am renting a one bdrm for $950 – if i move out tomorrow they will rent it for $1500. The fact that they could have possibly gotten $1600 in January doesn’t really matter to them as they will still see a $550 dollar increase in rent.

Introvert
Introvert
July 17, 2020 1:33 pm

We’ve seen very strong increases in rents in the past couple years, so anyone moving out now where the tenants have been living there for a couple years will likely be able to re-rent for higher.

Yeah, my tenant of eight years has had a red-hot deal on rent for a while now, so maybe it’ll return to market value!

I’m not miffed, though. A great tenant paying less is always better than a terrible tenant paying more, in my books.

Anna Edwards
Anna Edwards
July 17, 2020 1:22 pm

Leo S. Also a good point. We’ve seen very strong increases in rents in the past couple years, so anyone moving out now where the tenants have been living there for a couple years will likely be able to re-rent for higher.

Huh, what?

Whale Tales
Whale Tales
July 17, 2020 12:07 pm

Soak it in while you can with high rents, however I think this is going to carry major momentum to the downside… As a Landlord myself “outside of Victoria” I can see that the writing is on the wall for a massive rental correction.. It’s going to hurt a lot of “brilliant” investors who thought that they could cap on this market forever, the good times are over for a while it’s time to Hedge yourselves and play it safe.. What I would like to know is how many speculative owners in Victoria had interest only loans on these rentals… Any data on that?

alexandracdn
alexandracdn
July 17, 2020 10:57 am

2ndary suites: Of course you have to declare the income for these suites….whether you call them legal or illegal. But, if you purchased your primary residence with the suite already in place, and the owners part of the home is greater in size, and you don’t claim the C.C. Allowance, then you will not have to pay capital gains on that part of your residence that is the suite on the sale of your home.

MaxBravo
MaxBravo
July 17, 2020 10:55 am

I’m seeing turnover in my rental units, and hearing the same from other landlords. Apparently lots of movement in the rental market right now.

But I haven’t had to drop rents to attract tenants. Rents were already lower than market rate because of limits on increases the past few years. So I’m bumping up a little, but it just brings me to market rates. So far so good…

freedom_2008
freedom_2008
July 17, 2020 10:28 am

From CBC: “Rental market ‘softening’ in Victoria while remaining steady in Kelowna”: https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/rental-market-softening-in-victoria-while-remaining-steady-in-kelowna-1.5652617

That makes me wondering about Marko’s comment of “There is HHV and then you step out into reality”. Maybe people (i.e. landlords) only like to share good rental experiences here, and avoid talking about the bad ones? Or only those with good experiences will post on HHV?

freedom_2008
freedom_2008
July 17, 2020 10:05 am

We might see fewer exemptions for capital gains on secondary suites, but I don’t see anything happening beyond that on principal residences.

Or to start CG only over certain cap, say over $500K (or $750K) gain on a PR sale. Better to start saving all receipts of house reno/upgrades. 😉

patriotz
patriotz
July 17, 2020 9:01 am

“Interesting if true”

If it were true I would think the Conservatives would be all over it, but maybe they’re too busy fighting each other at the moment.

Also I think economically it would be a bad idea, since it would encourage people to carry as much debt on their mortgages as they could.

We might see fewer exemptions for capital gains on secondary suites, but I don’t see anything happening beyond that on principal residences.

rush4life
rush4life
July 17, 2020 8:30 am

Introvert that is interesting – AHS disagrees – more than 50 cases connected to that condo in the verve – Alberta Health Services believes: “The agency believes high-touch areas, particularly in regards to the building’s elevators, had a lot to do with how many people got sick.”. 50 out of 400 is pretty substantial.

https://calgary.ctvnews.ca/more-than-50-cases-of-covid-19-connected-to-calgary-condo-building-1.5008655

Introvert
Introvert
July 17, 2020 8:23 am

The risk of catching COVID-19 from contaminated surfaces, objects is ‘negligible,’ scientist says

https://www.theglobeandmail.com/canada/article-the-risk-of-catching-covid-19-from-contaminated-surfaces-objects-is/

Frank
Frank
July 17, 2020 3:54 am

I’m always amazed that the words “composting toilet “ never comes out of the mouth of environmentalists or politicians. As far as I’m concerned, you are not an environmentalist if you flush a toilet. Not only do you not produce sewage but you also save approximately 30% of household water consumption. The other benefit is your excrement turns into compost that can be used as fertilizer.
I have a composting toilet at my cottage that doesn’t get a lot of use but I’m at least familiar with one. The only thing needed to install one is a vent outside and an electrical outlet for a heater that evaporates urine.
This could also create another form of employment, people servicing the toilets, removing the compost for recycling and replenishing the start up material. This would be provided to people not wanting to do the dirty work. This will probably never fly and that is one reason humanity is doomed. By the way, in the slums of Mumbai it was reported that one “toilet “ is shared by 1400 people. Lovely.

Sideliner
Sideliner
July 16, 2020 9:11 pm

God forbid we enrich the ocean with nutrients and cause an abundance of sea life.

Go ahead and spread it on your vegetable patch and let us know how that works out for you.

Panko
Panko
July 16, 2020 5:43 pm

You can always tell a native Victorian from someone that moved here later in life. The native Victorian literally believes that their sh!t don’t stink. The rest of us are appalled that in 2020 we are still dumping our raw sewage in the ocean.

Introvert
Introvert
July 16, 2020 5:24 pm

God forbid we enrich the ocean with nutrients and cause an abundance of sea life.

Yeah, WTF are all those other coastal cities in North America doing treating their sewage, amirite?

Mt. Tolmie Foothills
Mt. Tolmie Foothills
July 16, 2020 4:51 pm

More importantly, we could not continue to pour raw sewage into the ocean from an ethical/environmental standpoint.

God forbid we enrich the ocean with nutrients and cause an abundance of sea life.

Introvert
Introvert
July 16, 2020 4:36 pm

The feds recently extended the deadline to 2040. We didn’t have to spend the $775M after all.

Oh well, it’s only money.

$775M today is better than who-knows-how-much in 2040.

More importantly, we could not continue to pour raw sewage into the ocean from an ethical/environmental standpoint.

Mt. Tolmie Foothills
Mt. Tolmie Foothills
July 16, 2020 4:31 pm

$775M Greater Victoria sewage treatment plant nears completion

The feds recently extended the deadline to 2040. We didn’t have to spend the $775M after all.

Oh well, it’s only money.

Introvert
Introvert
July 16, 2020 4:30 pm
Introvert
Introvert
July 16, 2020 4:15 pm

Good news.

$775M Greater Victoria sewage treatment plant nears completion

https://vancouverisland.ctvnews.ca/775m-greater-victoria-sewage-treatment-plant-nears-completion-1.5027568

Introvert
Introvert
July 16, 2020 4:13 pm

I guess it’s like getting married, without the sex.

Cue Barrister chiming in that, on second thought, it is just like getting married.

patriotz
patriotz
July 16, 2020 4:09 pm

It can work well but you need a detailed written co-ownership agreement

Brings to mind a pre-nup. I guess it’s like getting married, without the sex. 🙂

Way back when I was looking at such an arrangement but the partner backed out. Than the market crashed and I bought by myself.

totoro
totoro
July 16, 2020 3:36 pm

I’m curious if any of you have any experience with buying a home with a shared ownership?

It can work well but you need a detailed written co-ownership agreement (https://www.ratehub.ca/blog/files/2014/02/Mixer_Mortgage_Co-Ownership_Agreement_Checklist.pdf).
Van City offers a mortgage for this purpose.
https://www.vancity.com/Mortgages/TypesOfMortgages/MixerMortgage/

Rook
Rook
July 16, 2020 3:07 pm

I’m curious if any of you have any experience with buying a home with a shared ownership?
Risk adverse is my middle name, to my detriment sometimes. I have always thought this scenario would be wrought with potential future pain. Recently friend proposed to me that we do just this with his small family in the basement suite and us up top. I have been thinking about it a lot lately as it opens doors for us to enter into the market and into a home we would potentially be excited to move into.
Would love to hear from anybody that any experience with this.
Thanks.

Barrister
Barrister
July 16, 2020 2:41 pm

It may not be rational but I am beginning to feel like we are in one of those Titanic moments where people dont realize how wounded the ship actually is at this point.

Barrister
Barrister
July 16, 2020 2:39 pm

Freedom: Hope that your doctor had your heart and kidneys tested since Covid attacks those as well.

freedom_2008
freedom_2008
July 16, 2020 1:35 pm

In the early stages a lot of people that had symptoms were told to quarantine without getting tested, due to lack of tests.

I know as I am one of them. Actually the symptoms stayed and kept changing (including a terrible multi-day non-stop bloody diarrhea that an ambulance sent me to RJH ER at midnight. But doctors couldn’t find a cause after all the tests (no Covid test for some reason). I only started to feel normal recently after 3 months prolonged sickness/weakness. 🙁

Former Landlord
Former Landlord
July 16, 2020 12:55 pm

That is around eight times more B.C. residents have been infected than the number of cases reported.

Even if accurate, this is not that surprising. In the early stages a lot of people that had symptoms were told to quarantine without getting tested, due to lack of tests.

freedom_2008
freedom_2008
July 16, 2020 11:20 am

My estimate from talking to students is about a third will not return to campus in the fall.

Did you talk to any international students? I would say for those who have left, more than two third international students may not return. Also probably most new 1st year (undergrad) students wouldn’t need to come to campus at all in the fall.

Those low quality basement suite student rentals will be hurt (forced rent adjustment or be vacant) , plus those room and board student rentals. I know a family who used to supply room&board (three big upstairs bedrooms each with and ensuite at $1400+/m each) to UVic students, they are always full for past 4 years, but has no student since end of March this year, and no one booking for Sept either.

patriotz
patriotz
July 16, 2020 10:28 am

Airbnb Faces Backlash After Asking People to Donate to Hosts With ‘Kindness Cards’

According to USA Today, Airbnb recently sent out emails to guests asking them to send “kindness cards” to their past hosts. The cards are basically a digital comment card that guests can write an encouraging message on, with the option to add a monetary contribution to their host.

The email campaign is in response to hardships that hosts have had to endure while people are staying at home to combat the spread of coronavirus. The email to guests reads, “Like all of us, hosts on Airbnb are impacted by COVID-19, and many of them are unable to welcome guests. Now more than ever, it’s important to reach out and support one another—even in small ways,” USA Today reported.

Just when you thought you’d heard everything, Airbnb comes to the rescue.

patriotz
patriotz
July 16, 2020 10:23 am

Toronto sees 52% spike in furnished condo listings, pointing to Airbnb conversions

The Greater Toronto Area is seeing an increase of furnished condos hitting the long-term rental market as investors flee Airbnb and related services because of bylaws and travel restrictions that have severely reduced bookings.

In the second quarter, there were 1,877 furnished condo units offered for 12-month leases, an increase of 52 per cent from a year ago, according to new figures from real estate consulting firm Urbanation. Furnished units accounted for 12 per cent of all condo rental listings in the GTA last quarter, along with 21 per cent of the growth in listings compared to a year earlier.

freedom_2008
freedom_2008
July 16, 2020 9:49 am

FYI: A recent sero-prevalence research study (looking for antibodies in the blood samples of a random group of people) estimates less than one per cent of British Columbians were infected with coronavirus by the time first wave restrictions were eased in May. That is around eight times more B.C. residents have been infected than the number of cases reported:

https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/serology-study-vancouver-1.5650758

strangertimes
strangertimes
July 16, 2020 8:17 am

“Article on the market in Toronto.. Hits on a few themes commonly discussed here.”

Yes Toronto is seeing the same thing happen there with average prices in June hitting a record high from an increase in luxury sales
https://twitter.com/areacode416/status/1280546759001939968

Ks112
Ks112
July 16, 2020 8:11 am

Bear trap might be getting tighter , may want to consider getting out while you still can.

totoro
totoro
July 16, 2020 7:22 am

Our students decided to come back for September. They’d much rather live together in Victoria for the school year again then stay in Alberta with their parents over the winter. A lot of students have budgeted for rent and have RESPs and parental assistance with this. In addition, they’ve received six months of CERB or CESB.

Viclandlord
Viclandlord
July 15, 2020 11:41 pm

Leo, surprisingly we had a fair amount of student inquiries, with the den being a decent size with a nice large window it can easily be used as a bedroom.

I thought the student rental market would have been dead especially at our price point

Umm..really?
Umm..really?
July 15, 2020 10:07 pm
Barrister
Barrister
July 15, 2020 9:58 pm

2500 for a thousand square foot apartment. I am out of touch but that seems like a lot of money for a small place.
Nice to get some exchange with reality.

Marko Juras
July 15, 2020 9:36 pm

Lots of comments of rents dropping

There is HHV and then you step out into reality.

Introvert
Introvert
July 15, 2020 9:24 pm

Leo

Can you list the addresses of over 2 mln that sold and for how much? Redfin isn’t showing me any.

I see Stevo’s back, and a little more anonymous this time.

Sent you an email Steve.

And Leo provides concierge service upon request.

Viclandlord
Viclandlord
July 15, 2020 8:26 pm

Lots of comments of rents dropping …..we had our second set of tenants give notice since covid started, because they both bought houses.
We listed the unit July 1 and now have the lease signed & deposit paid today

2 bed/den 1 bath unit 1000sqft , top floor of character house that was gutted and renovated 3 years ago
Previous rent 2495 plus utilities ( tenant was there two years )

rented today for 2595 plus utilities
We did 7 showings and 2 of those were video showings, We canceled the other 6 showings we had this week.

Steve
Steve
July 15, 2020 6:50 pm

Leo

Can you list the addresses of over 2 mln that sold and for how much? Redfin isn’t showing me any.

totoro
totoro
July 15, 2020 3:20 pm

Germany and Ireland

Both countries which have made mask wearing mandatory nationally on all public transport and both countries that have reopened cautiously. Ireland is extending mandatory masks to all indoor public spaces and nearly all states in Germany already mandate this when shopping.

Israelis are wearing masks but they reopened really quickly after early success and sent kids back to school in May and opened bars, nightclubs and synagogues. Tokyo’s cases have risen (70% of new cases are aged 20s-30s) but the overall infection rate is really low comparatively and they have not reinstated their state of emergency.

Introvert
Introvert
July 15, 2020 3:08 pm

WestJet and Air Canada started selling middle seats on aircraft on July 1st.

“COVID-19 cases have been reported among passengers on 10 domestic flights and 16 international flights since June 29. ”

https://www.ctvnews.ca/health/coronavirus/at-least-26-flights-have-arrived-in-canada-with-covid-19-cases-in-last-two-weeks-1.5024278

Also, I think “Covid fatigue” is setting in, a bit. The weather’s nice all across Canada, finally. Everyone’s been cooped up. There’s a “Screw it, I’m gonna have some fun” attitude that may be becoming more common, especially in the under-40 crowd.

Patrick
Patrick
July 15, 2020 2:11 pm

Germany and Ireland have managed to keep CoVid numbers down (similar to Canada) despite their restaurants being busier now than they were a year ago! Canada restaurant numbers still down 50%.
https://www.opentable.com/state-of-industry

James Soper
James Soper
July 15, 2020 1:45 pm

Yep. Not a political point, just saying even countries who did very well at first can see increases in cases. Given BC has done well so far it seems relevant that it could all deteriorate fairly quickly.

I know you’re not making a political point. I guess I just don’t get that same impression from Nate specifically which I found surprising.

freedom_2008
freedom_2008
July 15, 2020 12:54 pm

Heard from a friend who just started building a house (duplex) that banks stopped issuing new construction loans (since March/April? May be just temporary? ). They are lucky that they got theirs last Dec.

freedom_2008
freedom_2008
July 15, 2020 12:45 pm

Many countries that did well at the beginning are now seeing resurgences.

We (BC) could face the same, if people are too relaxed and not as careful as we should be.

patriotz
patriotz
July 15, 2020 11:32 am

Like are they purchased at prices below “market value”

A property only sells below “market value” if there is somebody willing and able to pay more than the buyer but is excluded for some reason.

ks112
ks112
July 15, 2020 11:16 am

are all these luxury sales value buys? Like are they purchased at prices below “market value” I know there are homes in the high end range that are essentially selling at 2014/15 prices.

James Soper
James Soper
July 15, 2020 10:23 am

Many countries that did well at the beginning are now seeing resurgences.

Are those from Nate Silver?
I don’t know if I buy the argument that Japan and Australia are having issues yet.
It’s interesting that he seems to downplay the severity in the US but is expressing concern for other countries who are having much less of an issue that individual states right now.

Israel is the one where things have spun very out of control.

Israel is 50% larger population-wise than Arizona, but has half of the daily cases of Arizona.

Frank
Frank
July 15, 2020 10:07 am

Trudeau will be on CERB soon.

Introvert
Introvert
July 15, 2020 9:21 am

Thousands of businesses are going to fail across the country and I expect a great percentage of them will result in a foreclosure.

Don’t worry, Trudeau will pay the WE group to deliver motivational speeches to at-risk business owners.

Frank
Frank
July 15, 2020 8:49 am

A lot of businesses are financed with residential home equity. Trying to get a business loan from a bank is nearly impossible without some collateral. Thousands of businesses are going to fail across the country and I expect a great percentage of them will result in a foreclosure. Give it another few months then look out.

Former Landlord
Former Landlord
July 14, 2020 9:47 pm

I wonder if the luxury listings going up is due to certain business owners getting into financial difficulty. Especially thr ones that are conceding on price.

Barrister
Barrister
July 14, 2020 9:35 pm

My guess is that some out of town money is moving into retirement mode and cocooning in Victoria.

Rush4life
Rush4life
July 14, 2020 7:59 pm

Leo or Marko any ideas why suddenly the over 1 million are flying off the shelves?

Also KS I once referenced the rental.ca report and now I see it was wrong to. According to the report rental prices went up 15 percent just in June. Clearly working with bad data. https://rentals.ca/national-rent-report

totoro
totoro
July 14, 2020 5:24 pm

Or maybe they are all escaping from upscale elevators.

totoro
totoro
July 14, 2020 4:58 pm

four sales over $3 million today….insane.

You can get 2.05% on a five-year variable mortgage for over one million right now – less for under. Makes the monthly payment about $4000 on a million.

patriotz
patriotz
July 14, 2020 4:39 pm

Albertans are such takers.

Chart says % of total population. Alberta has the highest proportion of the population in the workforce of any province. They have the smallest proportion of retirees of any province. Note the provinces at the bottom have the highest proportion of retirees.

A meaningful comparison would be % of active workforce.

Marko Juras
July 14, 2020 4:31 pm

four sales over $3 million today….insane.

Introvert
Introvert
July 14, 2020 4:22 pm

CREB by province chart

Albertans are such takers.

freedom_2008
freedom_2008
July 14, 2020 2:16 pm

CREB by province chart again (sorry the image before didn’t seem to work, and can’t delete it).

Added: it seems to work afterwards, but can’t deleted this one now 😉

CREB by province.jpg
Introvert
Introvert
July 14, 2020 2:02 pm

Encouraging insight into Covid from a local researcher:
https://www.capnews.ca/news/how-covid-19-ends

As per totoro’s post, I feel like The Capital should stick to its bread and butter: local news/issues.

Introvert
Introvert
July 14, 2020 1:56 pm

$12.5B deficit.

The entire provincial deficit in a pandemic year is the same cost as one Site C dam.

totoro
totoro
July 14, 2020 1:51 pm

Encouraging insight into Covid from a local researcher.

Would be nice if true but, unfortunately, we still don’t know. The author is a Phd biochem candidate at UVic. There are lots of peer-reviewed journal articles by medical researchers and epidemiologists that are saying:

  1. There is some evidence that all people do not develop immunity after covid or, if they do, it is time-limited; https://www.statnews.com/2020/06/11/coronavirus-immunity-vaccine-development/
  2. Natural herd immunity is both unethical and impossible to achieve;
    https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7336129/
  3. There is evidence of aerosol transmission rather than just droplet. This means indoor ventilation systems can be conduits which is not good news for schools come fall; https://www.cebm.net/study/covid-19-aerosol-transmission-of-covid-19/
  4. If you get covid, no matter what your age and how mild, there is a possibility of long-lasting damage to organs beyond the respiratory system – extending to heart, brain and digestive tract. https://thehill.com/changing-america/well-being/prevention-cures/506752-mild-cases-of-coronavirus-may-not-be-as-mild-as

Dr. Fauci and the US Surgeon General have both stated it was a mistake not to recommend masks from the beginning and that failing to do so at the start has made it more difficult to get public buy-in which has cost lives and had an economic impact. It is a mistake not to require them here in indoor spaces too. It makes no sense to open up and not take all reasonable steps to contain transmission.

Marko Juras
July 14, 2020 12:25 pm

Estimates ~470B decline in PTT revenues.

you mean million

Introvert
Introvert
July 14, 2020 12:16 pm

Had to push back on a bit of sillyness from MMM recently: https://twitter.com/LeoSpalteholz/status/1280521959663525894?s=20

The trouble with mavericks who find extreme success by not following the crowd is that they often become overconfident and apply the same thinking to other areas, and it doesn’t go so well.

late30
late30
July 14, 2020 11:48 am

test? not sure the comments RSS is working.

Introvert
Introvert
July 14, 2020 11:45 am

We put some weight equipment (powercage, barbells) into our shed last spring. Great investment even outside of a pandemic.

Right out of the Mr Money Mustache playbook!

5 year fixed rate as low as 1.76%
https://www.ratespy.com/covid-re-openings-too-soon-071314775

Looks like in retrospect the variable would have been the better way to go for me. But last November was eons ago!

Mind you, we’re paying off the mortgage so aggressively that the interest rate doesn’t matter a whole heck of a lot.

Former Landlord
Former Landlord
July 14, 2020 10:23 am

Encouraging insight into Covid from a local researcher:
https://www.capnews.ca/news/how-covid-19-ends

QT
QT
July 14, 2020 9:46 am

Don’t expect and haven’t seen any discount of local seafood this season

I don’t know what the prices are like at Thrifty, but dungeness crabs was $15/lbs for A grade and $10/lbs for B grade last week at Hi Gear Seafood (Fisherman Wharf) that normally go for around $20-21/lbs for A grade and $14-15/lbs for B grade this time of year, B grade lobster (Atlantic) were $11/lbs.

Friend of the family with an oyster farm said last weekend that they can’t sell oyster and the price is down this year.

freedom_2008
freedom_2008
July 14, 2020 9:13 am

At the moment we can enjoy local seafood at a discount, and support our local economy by buys local food & produce

We always buy local food as much as possible (even if they are a bit more expensive). Don’t expect and haven’t seen any discount of local seafood this season (fresh halibuts are still around $3 -$5/100g at Thrifty, live spots pawns are still $20/lb at Oak Bay seafood), but that is fine and all good with us, and they taste so fresh and good. 🙂

QT
QT
July 14, 2020 8:48 am

A fisherman friend tells me prices have plummeted for boutique BC seafood items in China and Japan, hurting local producers.

At the moment we can enjoy local seafood at a discount, and support our local economy by buys local food & produce, and manufacture goods (made in Canada cars, bicycles, etc…). Lobby for Canadian minerals to be use in products that are sold in Canada, and lobby the government to stop wasting money on incentives that promote foreign products.

Marko Juras
July 14, 2020 8:47 am

The perctange of sales right now over $1 million is insane…we may be looking at another $1+ million average this month.

Marko Juras
July 14, 2020 8:46 am

Is it safe to assume that I would have no chance of actually purchasing one of the lower-priced houses like 429658 or 429621 because they’ll all end up with 15 offers and go for $200k over ask?

You have to go a bit over asking with a clean offer and 6-7 days for conditions. I had a listing at 750k, and we had 6 offers on it ranging from 750 to 783k but ended up going with a 765k with short conditions. So Leo is right, 5-10 offers doesn’t mean 200k over asking right now.

With all the uncertainty terms are pretty important. I had buyers lose out to an unconditional competing offer that was 30k less but can’t blame the seller. Who knows where the market is at in 10 days if your conditional offers walks for no reason.

patriotz
patriotz
July 14, 2020 7:52 am

without any government assistance (another round of CERB and also mortgage deferral)

Mortgage deferral isn’t assistance, it’s digging the hole deeper. Also anyone who can afford to buy a house is not going to be making up lost salary with what CERB pays, or what EI would pay.

DuranDuran
DuranDuran
July 14, 2020 7:52 am

Barrister –

Festivals and events (music, art, food, business, weddings) and therefore hospitality, catering, transportation (you wouldn’t believe the lame car rental ads I keep getting in my spam box).

With less going out and hosting, I would guess fashion and design.

With economic declines, a lot of discretionary spending drops suddenly. A fisherman friend tells me prices have plummeted for boutique BC seafood items in China and Japan, hurting local producers. I’m sure there are many similar products.

Barrister
Barrister
July 14, 2020 5:36 am

I am trying to figure out what categories of jobs are looking at longer term losses. Restaurants and some retail are the obvious ones that come to mind. Almost anything that is driven by tourism. What other groupings come to mind?

Introvert
Introvert
July 13, 2020 9:15 pm

comment image

BTW, lovin’ the work coming out of HHV’s graphics department lately.

James Soper
James Soper
July 13, 2020 8:24 pm

No there were 2 new island cases on Friday.

It says the 9th, which was Thursday, but maybe that’s what they were talking about. They said it was local transmission, and in Victoria.

James Soper
James Soper
July 13, 2020 7:28 pm

July 10-12 cases just announced and no additional cases on the Island. Still 135.

That’s good news. Means who i heard it from is dead wrong.

strangertimes
strangertimes
July 13, 2020 7:11 pm

I read on some twitter feed that study permits will be required for online courses so we won’t know how many students physically arrive in Canada this year from just this data

Canada study permit holders
2015- 219,045
2016- 264,315
2017- 315,130
2018- 354,745
2019- 402.260
Jan-May 2020- 96,730

BC study permit holders
2015- 56,760
2016- 65,665
2017- 76,420
2018- 81,675
2019- 85,965
Jan-May 2020- 22,980

Victoria study permit holders (data only up to first quarter 2018)
2015- 6415
2016- 9605
2017- 11,585
https://open.canada.ca/data/en/dataset/90115b00-f9b8-49e8-afa3-b4cff8facaee

rush4life
rush4life
July 13, 2020 7:04 pm

KS i made the move to government a few years back. Pay is same and work life balance is much better – allowing me to work on the side. Benefits are much better as well. I think having both the tenant and my wife lose work is less likely as well – but something to consider. its a good rule of thumb i think for the one paycheque which is about right assuming my wife is working. but if she doesn’t things get tight quick.

The way I like to look at things is if something somewhat forseeable happens, will i feel stupid about the choices i made that got me there. In this case i see a plausible conversation with a friend in a year going like such: “so you bought your house at near peak prices” “yup” “in the middle of a pandemic” “yup” “right after you wife went back to work, looking at the possibility of a round 2 of covid” “yup” “knowing rents were dropping” “yup” “and now you are stressed about money and the future” “…..yup”.

I see that as a realistic scenario and so for now i will wait.

Patrick
Patrick
July 13, 2020 4:49 pm

Sounds like we’ve got 2 new local cases that are local transmission. Hopefully the contact trace the hell out of them.

July 10-12 cases just announced and no additional cases on the Island. Still 135.

ks112
ks112
July 13, 2020 4:49 pm

Rush4 life, what sector do you work in now that you are not in banking anymore? My thoughts on mortgage affordability is that as a single person you should be able to cover all your housing expenses with one pay chq (not counting suit rental) and use the other one to live on every month. This is assuming your take home pay is atleast $3k a month, I wouldn’t try that with a $2k a month take home as having $2k to live on doesn’t provide much of a buffer for life events.

I think you can use something similar in your situation but include your wife’s pay. What you are assuming right now is a little too aggressive in my opinion because the chances of COVID #2 comes and both risk items materialize for you (wife not working and tenant not paying) without any government assistance (another round of CERB and also mortgage deferral) is fairly slim.

freedom _2008
freedom _2008
July 13, 2020 3:33 pm

Of single family properties listed under $750k sold in the last 4 weeks, 30% sold over ask so two third still going at or under. Biggest over ask was $105k over, but that is an outlier due to a purposefully underpriced listing. Most over ask sales are only a few percent over. Of the 32 over-asks, 81% were within 5% of the asking price, and 60% are within 2%.

These are good and valuable information, for potential buyers or anyone who are interested in the housing market, much more useful and accurate than one (or ten) example of sales here and there. Two Thumbs up to you Leo!

Former Landlord
Former Landlord
July 13, 2020 3:26 pm

For those concerned (or happy) about lack of students cratering the rental market. This might be (partially) offset by US hostility to foreign students.

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-07-13/as-u-s-turns-hostile-foreign-student-permits-climb-in-canada

Lost Soul
July 13, 2020 3:07 pm

Thanks for the good reading Leo!

I wonder if there will be lots of rude surprises come tax time.

I was in Vancouver recently and noticed graffiti downtown that was encouraging anyone with a SIN to collect CERB. Judging by the numbers Leo mentioned a lot of the recipients would not have qualified and simply didn’t care. A lot of money pissed away that could have been better allocated. I’d be happy to know that someone used their CERB payment to justify an over ask offer or to increase their downpayment by $10K instead of wasting it on alcohol and drugs.

In any event lots of bankruptcies to come as a result of non-payment following next tax season.

James Soper
James Soper
July 13, 2020 2:21 pm

Sounds like we’ve got 2 new local cases that are local transmission. Hopefully the contact trace the hell out of them.

Introvert
Introvert
July 13, 2020 2:03 pm

Exercised at the rec centre for the first time since they shut down. Nice to be back!

It was funny, though. Before we entered, we’re all lined up outside, two metres apart, and the rec centre employee is reading us the riot act (don’t use the water fountain, thoroughly disinfect equipment after use, don’t breathe moistly, etc.). As this is happening, two groups of summer camp kids are returning to the building and most kids are shoulder-to-shoulder with the kid next to them, some are grabbing their friend’s arm, others are receiving noogies — in short, zero physical distancing.

September’s full-school startup is gonna be interesting.

Josh
Josh
July 13, 2020 1:14 pm

Anyone got a contractor to recommend? Looking to do some basic stuff and hopefully have a conversation about a more major renovation (attic conversion).

FullTimeRemote
FullTimeRemote
July 13, 2020 1:04 pm

Thanks for the info Leo! That is encouraging.

FullTimeRemote
FullTimeRemote
July 13, 2020 12:54 pm

Is it safe to assume that I would have no chance of actually purchasing one of the lower-priced houses like 429658 or 429621 because they’ll all end up with 15 offers and go for $200k over ask?

rush4life
rush4life
July 13, 2020 11:33 am

interesting… could be that we are seeing peak affordability here and thats why there are not more over asks for that segment (100% speculation). But given the comment Marko just made it does make you think. I think we can all agree there is a peak price at some point in Victoria – individuals, unlike the government, can’t just conjure up money from thin air.

My fear about buying in this market is round two covid comes and my wife loses her job again (dental hygienist) or we buy and our tenant decides they can’t afford the mortgage and we only get $300 in lieu from the gov and we can’t kick them out for the next 6 months or more (not to mention rents seem to be more at risk then prices for dropping). A lot of risks right now IMO but as a former banker i know most people won’t think about those things – they just want to get in as everyone has told them just buy in are you will be rich (just like your parents who now have a million dollar property). Prices don’t drop in BC etc. Based on what the government is paying out i can’t say i disagree – seems like the ride will never end.

My choice is continuing to wait as i don’t want to be house poor. It could be prices are up 20% next year and we are priced out forever – thats a risk i’m willing to take – Honestly it may be a relief – right now we can barely qualify for a place for with a suite but if prices go up then it prices us out and take the option off the table – then i can stop thinking about it and visiting this site X times a day haha.

Your ad revenue may drop considerably of course Leo so I apologize in advance.

rush4life
rush4life
July 13, 2020 10:56 am

Leo can you break out what the SFH under a million over asks are?

Rook
Rook
July 13, 2020 10:56 am

Absolutely anecdotal here. I was on my way home from a camping trip in China beach last week and noticed a lot of for sale signs on the main Sooke road. I counted them and noted 25 for sale and 5 sold signs from otter point to kangaroo road. It seemed like a lot to me.

Marko Juras
July 13, 2020 10:44 am

detached market under a million is still nuts….just got this from a property I showed yesterday

We have two offers in hand. 8 more agent have indicated they are likely writing, and 2 may be writing.