2025 Predictions

Well it’s the time of year again when we look back at the predictions made for 2024 and how well they did (or more likely, didn’t) pan out.  There are dozens of people whose job it is to make predictions on behalf of banks, think tanks, real estate associations, or just professional TV experts, and what they all have in common is that after making a prediction they never mention it again.  While we’re no better at predicting the market, at least we face those predictions annually and reflect on how they turned out.  It’s always a good reminder that though there are metrics that correlate with future prices, in most cases the unknown unknowns or inherent randomness of the market will dominate short term performance.

So how did we do in 2024?  Well here are all the predictions made a year ago, along with the average absolute error in the forecasts (note % error for the first 4 plus the absolute difference between the forecasted and actual BoC rate).

NameSalesSingle FamilyCondoInventoryBoC RateAvg Error
alexandracdn6350111800052800023504.54.77%
Ashley B6800119000053000022004.253.85%
Avavee6400118000054500026504.257.98%
Bluebird5900117000051500024004.758.09%
Bobby C59521050000540000252559.74%
Boris7000120000054500023003.52.45%
Brandon M.7350121000049500018404.2511.16%
Cambo7100122500055000020003.756.90%
Carlo7200117800038100022404.511.09%
Cat5600103000052500024504.7510.90%
Chris S7100105000050500025503.757.55%
CondoHunter6800114000054000021804.753.19%
Dad6744109200053500024372.753.78%
Dinesh580095000046500028005.519.29%
DuranDuran81301155000515000220047.67%
DY58009800005200001980412.40%
fern654098400049890031003.715.76%
Frank650012500004500002600311.62%
GH SFH6400108000052200026504.58.98%
Glenalder61001140000525,60025004.57.05%
Gonzo Guy 7250125000054000024004.256.06%
Gwac800012500006250001300422.09%
Ira Willey600012000005000001900411.39%
iTz Nordic6700110000053500030004.2510.41%
James P6450119000054000022004.254.84%
Jane Marple8500115000063000017003.517.07%
Joyride6150107500051000025504.59.46%
Kenny660511053055056022407425426.28%
Krizzle825012670005500001900413.33%
Leo S6900110000051300026004.756.90%
LeonJ6506118300054150023074.754.25%
Lims5980103000050500024505.2510.95%
LongTimeObserver6500115000053000022504.53.76%
Marko Juras7000110000052500025004.55.36%
Megs (VIHM)585095000048500022004.2512.35%
Misha S.6500115000053000022004.254.05%
Mr. G6900114000053800021004.753.65%
Mrs. LeoS6600107000052800025004.756.80%
Ms. B6700110000054000025004.55.16%
Mt. Tolmie Foothills67001180000550000230043.05%
Pandit Ji7000110000058000030003.511.17%
Patrick6800119000052500029004.510.00%
Pepko7400118000055500028004.2510.13%
Pmac6100109900050550023004.756.84%
Pseudo Nymph 70331111333533,00027004.57.04%
Real Love6621115300052900026114.256.25%
Rob Reynolds590098000052000022225.2510.64%
Rodger6500100000050000030003.514.21%
Rush4Life601496300044800026841.7517.01%
SaanichAdam7250115000055000024004.254.33%
Silky7000100000050000030003.513.18%
Stan Evans587099900049900026504.7514.00%
successfulHomeBuyer70001200000500000180039.13%
The Underwriter65011170001549999270147.93%
Thomas69001160000529000240042.89%
Toothurty7800115500049500023504.57.58%
Ummm... really 580099999949999938005.2527.24%
Vanessa Roman6432116500054800022064.655.06%
Zach73001080000510,00024004.256.24%

The median prediction in each category was:

Sales: 6621
Single Family Median (Q4): $1,114,000
Condo Median (Q4): $526,800
December Inventory: 2400
Bank of Canada Rate: 4.25%

And the actual values for this year as well as the difference from the median guess:

Sales: 6893 (+4%)
Single Family Median (Q4): $1,137,500 (+2%)
Condo Median (Q4): $538,000 (+2%)
December Inventory:  2290 (-5%)
Bank of Canada Rate: 3.25% (-1 percentage point)

Overall the wisdom of the crowd did fairly well this year.  The median forecasts for prices were very close to the actuals, and sales were just a smidge higher than predicted while inventory slightly undershot.  The likely reason was rates, which dropped faster than most people anticipated to end at just 3.25% vs the median guess of 4.25%.

Winners

In the category of sales, there was a three-way tie for the win, with myself, Thomas, and Mr. G all guessing 6900, only 17 more than the actual number.

In house prices, another three-way tie, with Glenalder (who also won this category last year), Mr. G, and Condohunter all with a guesses of $1,140,000.

In condo prices, Mr. G guessed the actual of $538,000 dead on.

For inventory, a third three way tie with Pmac, Boris, and Mt. Tolmie Foothills each guessing 2300, just 10 over the total.

Incredibly, despite there being far fewer potential outcomes, not a single person predicted the Bank of Canada ending the year at 3.25%.  There were 4 people that thought we would end at or below 3%, but none exactly 3.25%.   Call it a collective miss.

Overall winner:  To calculate the overall winner, I averaged the percentage errors on each of the first estimates (percent errors on the bank rate messes this up a bit so I left it out) to determine the forecaster with the minimum error across the categories.

The winner, with an average absolute error of only 2.4%, was Boris.   Congratulations!  Not only did Boris predict sales, prices, and inventory quite well, they were one of the very few that got close on the central bank rate as well.  The runner up with an average error of 2.9% was Thomas.  Thanks everyone for putting in your predictions!

2025 Predictions

My medium term forecast has been pretty consistent for a few years now, with an expectation that the market will probably trade roughly sideways for a number of years while affordability returns via some combination of dropping rates, increasing incomes, and relatively minor price changes.  However the speed of the resurgence in activity last fall surprised me, and is now tilting the market into a stronger position than I anticipated it to be at this point.  On the detached side I think there’s a logical story to be told that dwindling greenfield land, increasing population density, and housing reforms are all working together to widen the gap between single family and multifamily housing.   The story for condos is less clear.  Yes we are building mostly rentals right now, but those markets are connected.   I’ve been assuming that developers could pivot back to condo supply fairly seamlessly, but the ones I’ve heard from are really struggling to make the numbers work at current condo pricing.  Has inflation in building materials simply made it too difficult to bring the supply online?  Or will condo supply come from investors bailing as they have to suddenly compete with abundant purpose built rentals?  It’s going to be interesting.

On the policy side there was continued action with some potentially effective reforms (upzoning and housing targets) and some that were more about optics than impact (STR bans and flipping tax).  The biggest federal policy move this year that will reverberate through the market in coming years were the immigration reforms, with the federal government slamming the brakes on non-permanent residents and even cutting back permanent immigration targets.  That should swing the country from record population growth to an outright decline, though the impact will likely be muted in Victoria (more on this later).  Less clear is how ambitious the province will be on further housing reforms.  There’s lots to do, but with a government hanging by a string will they have the political capital?   Recent announcements have been more about directly building housing, which – though I support public housing – simply has no chance of hitting the scale required to address the shortage.  Overall I don’t expect a lot of substantial new policies this year, though I hope they keep their foot on the gas for municipal implementation of the major zoning and planning reforms due to be completed this year.  There’s also a showdown coming between the province and municipalities with no desire to hit their housing targets, and so far it’s unclear who will back down from it.

Last year I figured that the stimulative effect from lower rates would be roughly counteracted by the weakening economy as has happened in the past.  While that was arguably the case in areas like Ontario with high unemployment rates, we didn’t really see the weakening out here with Victoria posting the lowest unemployment rate in the country in November.  That’s a departure from previous price corrections, when Victoria’s economy suffered at the same time.  Will it stay strong in 2025?  There are many headwinds including a government hiring freeze, and the anecdotes I hear are less positive than the official statistics.  However in construction and supporting industries it should be busy with everyone pushing projects through before new building codes hit in the spring.  Overall I suspect the economy will finally slow down this year, though it will likely remain on the stronger end compared to the national picture.

Here are my predictions for 2025, along with the historical values to help you make similar predictions:

  1. Sales: 7350.  If the sales rate we saw this fall continues we should land near 8000 sales.  However I think part of that was temporary pent up demand which will subside so I’m taking the under.  I don’t think bond yields will go much lower in 2025 and I expect fixed rates to hover at or just under 4% rather than continuing to drop much more.
  2. Single family Q4 2025 median: $1,195,000.  If we just look at market conditions and the trajectory in the past couple months, one would expect fairly significant positive price pressure in 2025.  And while I think there will be some, I still believe the sluggish national economy will catch up with us to some extent this year.  Thus I expect some increase in prices in the early part of of the year, but not a huge amount (~5%).  SSMUH zoning reforms should support land values, but based on what I’ve seen of local implementations I’m not convinced there will be big impacts in 2025.  I think the policies will need more work before we start to see results.
  3. Condo Q4 2025 median: $559,000.   I’ve consistently underestimated the performance of the condo market by predicting slight price declines that never arrived.  I suspect it’s a combo of a 30 year low in new ownership housing supply and rates that slid more than expected last year.  Affordability still isn’t great, but with lower rates and improving conditions I can’t imagine that 2025 will bring anything less than a small price increase.  On the bearish side, the rapidly weakening rental market will keep investors away, while renters will face less pressure to jump into a condo when rental choices are more abundant.  That’s why I’m keeping my projected increase small (4%) and a little bit lower than the detached side.
  4. Inventory:  2350.   Inventory is tricky.  Though the rapid increases have slowed down, the high number of cancelled listings make me think there’s a fair amount of frustrated sellers on the sidelines that will want to list in 2025.  I expect little growth this year, but still projecting a small increase 12 months from now.
  5. Bank of Canada rate:  2.75%  The central bank cut way faster than almost anyone expected in 2024, but I think we’re near the end of that cycle.  I expect two more quarter point cuts and then a wait and see approach.  I believe the weak dollar will put upward pressure on inflation which will complicate matters.

As usual we’re doing the same predictions in the Vancouver Island Housing Market Facebook group, so to facilitate collecting responses, I’ve set up a survey.

Click here to submit your predictions for 2025

If you want to keep track of the forecasts, they will show up in this spreadsheet of the results.

What do you think will happen in our housing market this year?  Leave your prediction for sales, single family price, condo price, inventory, and interest rates using the form above, then drop them in the comments below to discuss.

What else do you expect to happen this year?

guest
233 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Bobbyk
Bobbyk
January 13, 2025 6:20 pm

I’m sure Marko is like me in that it’s hard to leave money on the table even when you have more than enough money for several lifetimes. Whenever I need something substantial I first look on marketplace and often time I can find what I’m looking for at half of new price and no taxes, it’s like a fun game, then you feel no guilt when you treat your family on tropical vacation etc…

Westerly
Westerly
January 13, 2025 5:57 pm

BobbyK ‘if you already have a place to live it’s not urgent to move”. The urgency though is with the realtor. No deal no paycheck, hence “it is always a good time to sell.”

Introvert
Introvert
January 13, 2025 5:48 pm

Still sold it for double what Tesla offered me for trade in.

I seem to remember Marko saying a while ago that he was gonna trade in his S (and get less for it) because he didn’t want to deal with the huge hassle of selling it privately. I guess, at the end of the day, the money-making machine couldn’t bear to leave any money on the table!

Bobbyk
Bobbyk
January 13, 2025 3:34 pm

Max most of those products you mentioned have a more urgent need, if you already have a place to live it’s not urgent to move

Marko Juras
January 13, 2025 3:33 pm

I would have thought for sure all realtors would want the extra range….

Practically impossible to drive 300 km+ in a day around Victoria; therefore, whether the car has 400km or 500km of range seems rather irrelevant based on my experiences of driving EVs for the last 10 years and driving more km/year than 98% of the population.

RWD Model Ys also came with the LFP battery which you can charge to 100% every night without impacting long term battery health so the range is a already a lot better than my old Model S which I only charged to 80 to 85%.

Max
Max
January 13, 2025 3:30 pm

When you only have one product on the shelf to sell

What does a butcher sell, what does a florist sell, what does an asphalt paving company sell, what does a concrete batch plant sell, what does a quarry sell…etc?

VicREanalyst
VicREanalyst
January 13, 2025 3:10 pm

You lost me at respected realtor

He’s an IT guy that sold his company and then got into real estate, he was one of the earlier airbnb investors in town..

VicREanalyst
VicREanalyst
January 13, 2025 3:08 pm

+1, don’t need the extra range.

I would have thought for sure all realtors would want the extra range….

Bobby K
Bobby K
January 13, 2025 2:51 pm

“Here is a synopsis from a respected real estate agent”

You lost me at respected realtor. When you only have one product on the shelf to sell (homes), it’s always a good time to buy.

Marko Juras
January 13, 2025 2:31 pm

you must have gotten the RWD one then

+1, don’t need the extra range.

Max
Max
January 13, 2025 2:19 pm

Here is a synopsis from a respected real estate in Victoria of how he sees 2025

Groot, thanks for the vid. I liked what he was saying, I think he’s spot on.

Bobbyk
Bobbyk
January 13, 2025 2:06 pm

I don’t like Tesla’s so didn’t want one. My son drives the Kona everyday out to his hockey academy, I prefer to bike everywhere I can.

Thursty
January 13, 2025 2:00 pm

Groot , I liked what the young man was saying , he had a solid take . Buy a sfh in the core and u will make money this year imo.

I-am-Groot
I-am-Groot
January 13, 2025 1:43 pm

Here is a synopsis from a respected real estate in Victoria of how he sees 2025

https://youtu.be/hJyrN5QMQxw?si=NPEHbRX1MWh-4FRZ

VicREanalyst
VicREanalyst
January 13, 2025 1:28 pm

My new Model Y was 45k after fed + provincial rebates.

you must have gotten the RWD one then

Marko Juras
January 13, 2025 1:04 pm

unlikely you would have gotten a 1 year old AWD Model Y with reasonable kms for 45,500 all in.

Model Y re-sale values will now stabilize with the rebates gone. For a year or there so the market made absolutely no sense. Once Tesla slashed prices substantially people were asking more for used Model Ys then what you could buy one a new one for after rebates.

Marko Juras
January 13, 2025 1:02 pm

We bought a Kona Ultimate for 37K,

Even at 30% off not super cheap. My new Model Y was 45k after fed + provincial rebates.

Tesla did manage to screw me in that they promised via email/text to transfer the lifetime free supercharging from my Model S and then refused to do so afterwards because the Model Y was “discounted” for an end of quarter push. I ended up getting an extra $1,200 off and 6 months free supercharging. Then when I went to sell the Model S no one cared about the lifetime free supercharging as the car had 270,000 km+ on it. Still sold it for double what Tesla offered me for trade in.

Had a friend pick up a Cybertruck two weeks ago and then a week after he picked it up they started including lifetime supercharging with new Cybertruck deliveries. I don’t mind Tesla’s approach of constantly changing pricing/inclusions but it has a way of really pissing people off. Seems like people like the hidden “cash incentive” method of discounting at the dealership level versus transparency in change of MSRP.

Bobby K
Bobby K
January 13, 2025 12:53 pm

We bought a Kona Ultimate for 37K, we had a 2 year gas Kona that we traded in for 3K less than we paid so that credit covered most of the GST

Marko Juras
January 13, 2025 12:53 pm

I dont think many people who could afford a 50K plus electric vehicle got the Fed rebate anyways. We bought a 1 year old electric car last year which only had 15K mileage on it for about 30% off new price plus no PST.

The best selling EV in Canada was the Model Y and it qualified for the 5k rebate up until a couple of days ago so I would say a lot of people buying a 50k plus EV got the rebate?

There is going to be a lot more people that bought the 55k Model Y versus 180k Taycan.

I hope the rebates are gone forever. The cars are too good to need them. Once the refreshed Model Y hits the market in Canada later this year even without the rebates will likely be the best selling non-pickup vehicle in Canada.

VicREanalyst
VicREanalyst
January 13, 2025 12:52 pm

The land is assessed at $955,000 so the house is likely a liability.

Assessment of land also does not factor that it is surrounded by apartments, which would further diminish its value.

VicREanalyst
VicREanalyst
January 13, 2025 12:51 pm

We bought a 1 year old electric car last year which only had 15K mileage on it for about 30% off new price plus no PST.

Not sure what you got but a brand new AWD model Y last year with full incentives comes out to 65k out the door. unlikely you would have gotten a 1 year old AWD Model Y with reasonable kms for 45,500 all in.

Patrick
Patrick
January 13, 2025 12:40 pm

> I dont think many people who could afford a 50K plus electric vehicle got the Fed rebate anyways

Well there sure were a lot of people that still got the EV rebate, The Canada feds gave away $700 million in EV rebates in 2023 and $464 million in rebates in 2024. That’s a big waste of money that they needed to borrow and haven’t even begun to pay back. The main reason they’re stopping it is they’re (thankfully) running out of money.
https://www.auto123.com/en/news/federal-discounts-electric-vehicles-2023/71151/?utm_source=chatgpt.com

Arrow
Arrow
January 13, 2025 12:30 pm

James Bay at sub $900k is a rare find

The land is assessed at $955,000 so the house is likely a liability.

Bobby K
Bobby K
January 13, 2025 12:27 pm

I dont think many people who could afford a 50K plus electric vehicle got the Fed rebate anyways. We bought a 1 year old electric car last year which only had 15K mileage on it for about 30% off new price plus no PST.

VicREanalyst
VicREanalyst
January 13, 2025 12:21 pm

Just arguing for argument’s sake at this point. I’ll pass.

Good choice.

Joe
Joe
January 13, 2025 12:14 pm

How do you know the house is in good condition? This house has been on the market regularly since 2017 so it’s definitely a known product and got market price for it. This isn’t a new listing that someone snagged on the first day with an unconditional low ball offer.

Just arguing for argument’s sake at this point. I’ll pass.

Patrick
Patrick
January 13, 2025 12:12 pm

Finally, the feds end the $5,000 EV rebate. Well they’re actually “pausing” it, which is hopefully the government code word for “ending” it. At least they show some realization that they can’t just give away money when they have a $52 billion deficit.
Next up should be BC government, which still gives a $3k or $4k EV rebate to some buyers and corporations, despite BC having a $10 billion deficit.

https://ca.finance.yahoo.com/news/canada-pauses-electric-vehicle-rebates-worth-up-to-5000-for-buyers-163036035.html

VicREanalyst
VicREanalyst
January 13, 2025 12:11 pm

I think the trend is important. If there is another cut end of January more buyers will enter the market quicker versus if there is sentiment out there that BOC might pause the cuts.

Ok, I can roll with that thought process.

VicREanalyst
VicREanalyst
January 13, 2025 12:10 pm

While far from perfect, a 3 bed 2 bath detached in good condition with good features in James Bay at sub $900k is a rare find.

How do you know the house is in good condition? This house has been on the market regularly since 2017 so it’s definitely a known product and got market price for it. This isn’t a new listing that someone snagged on the first day with an unconditional low ball offer.

Marko Juras
January 13, 2025 12:04 pm

Maybe if you want to play the developer angle.

Lot too small for any sort of economics from that angle.

Marko Juras
January 13, 2025 12:03 pm

a 25 bps cut still puts all mortgages in the 4% range. Don’t see how that can move the market, psychology only does so much.

I think the trend is important. If there is another cut end of January more buyers will enter the market quicker versus if there is sentiment out there that BOC might pause the cuts.

Then on the flip side we will have the highest active inventory end of January that we’ve seen in a decade.

@Marko, the single family detached market in Victoria core is looking very sparse – that could be a hotter segment

If something is going to hold in there it is core SFHs.

Joe
Joe
January 13, 2025 11:59 am

While far from perfect, a 3 bed 2 bath detached in good condition with good features in James Bay at sub $900k is a rare find. I think there are many that would gladly choose it over similarly priced alternatives.

VicREanalyst
VicREanalyst
January 13, 2025 11:55 am

If no BOC cut end of January I predict a challenging spring market.

a 25 bps cut still puts all mortgages in the 4% range. Don’t see how that can move the market, psychology only does so much.

VicREanalyst
VicREanalyst
January 13, 2025 11:51 am

Whoever bought it this time got a great deal in my opinion.

A sfh surrounded apartments? Maybe if you want to play the developer angle. I wouldn’t want to live there as a long term home.

Joe
Joe
January 13, 2025 11:36 am

Looks better than the absolutely eye-popping stats out of the GVR and Fraser Valley last week.

SKS
SKS
January 13, 2025 11:31 am

@Marko, the single family detached market in Victoria core is looking very sparse – that could be a hotter segment

Marko Juras
January 13, 2025 11:25 am

Month Jan Jan
Year 2025 2024
New Unconditional Sales 100 341
New Listings 369 960
Active Listings 2,202 2,140

Last year we had 95 sales as of Jan 15th so sales pace running ahead of last year, but also about 100 active listings more than last year at same time.

If no BOC cut end of January I predict a challenging spring market.

Joe
Joe
January 13, 2025 11:14 am

Whoever bought it this time got a great deal in my opinion. Seller must have been desperate.

Josh
Josh
January 13, 2025 11:12 am

House sold for big loss of 26% plus fees over 2 years.

That house is the one I’m talking about where several flippers would just paint the door a different color and resell it a few months later at a huge profit. No one lives there for long.

Bobby K
Bobby K
January 13, 2025 11:03 am
I-am-Groot
I-am-Groot
January 13, 2025 10:39 am

Modular homes retain their value over time since they are usually counted the same as regular homes. Similar to traditional homes, modular homes only lose value if they are in poor condition or a bad location.

Many studies have shown that modular homes can appreciate value similarly to traditional homes. The depreciation rate of modular homes has been thought to be a myth, and when correctly maintained, these homes can appreciate at the same rate as regular homes.

There may be still some stigma associated with prefabricated homes, but this perception is changing as technology and design improves. In View Royal there is a circa 1995 subdivision of modular homes that were built to a higher earthquake standard than traditional construction of that time. Unless the buyer is told that they are prefabricated modular homes they can not be distinguished from traditional construction except for the foundation lip and shear wall construction which typical homes of that era did not have. After 30 years they have stood the test of time.

The listings in this subdivision, that I have reviewed, along with their property disclosure statements do not show any abnormal defects due to their type of construction. In almost all cases the fact that they are modular homes is not mentioned in the listings. In fact the opposite is quoted that the subdivision as being “highly sought-after”.

In my opinion, a modular home can be built and designed to be just as appealing as traditional construction. A lot depends on the subdivision as the housing style may be overly redundant. Easily fixed by providing more variety in home styles.

VicREanalyst
VicREanalyst
January 13, 2025 7:40 am

5 year yield back up above 3.2 now, crazy.

Frank
Frank
January 13, 2025 5:27 am

Proof that investing in real estate has its risks with no guarantee of making money.

Muggins
Muggins
January 12, 2025 9:37 pm

3123 cedar Hill did sell for more then 2022, but they did do some updating (paint, new W/D etc).

3123 Cedar Hill Rd, Victoria, British Columbia V8T3J4 Sold History | HouseSigma
https://housesigma.com/bc/victoria-real-estate/3123-cedar-hill-rd/home/XRla7gxb2qg3jEvL?id_listing=jAXw7QpveeayQOzg&utm_campaign=listing&utm_source=user-share&utm_medium=iOS&ign=

4015 Loyola, looks like it was a possible “investment property?” Rental? I bet they’re happy to have sold it for $1,110,000

The original asking of $1,248,000 was
Listed: 2024-03-14 and expired: 2024-09-27

4015 Loyola St, Saanich, British Columbia V8N3R6 Sold History | HouseSigma
https://housesigma.com/bc/saanich-real-estate/4015-loyola-st/home/2Zpj39EqK8z3DrK8?id_listing=AKv53DlLWm53MnxB&utm_campaign=listing&utm_source=user-share&utm_medium=iOS&ign=

Max
Max
January 12, 2025 5:29 pm

What happens when the price of Lego blocks does a moonshot?

Arrow
Arrow
January 12, 2025 5:21 pm

Max, Please Mute me (or at least stop replying to my posts.)

This one has nothing to do with prefab. The one constant on this forum is your negativity; the number of times you have shot down other people’s ideas is astounding (everything from diet to voting preference to Croatia to debt to…), the only thing you speak positively about is yourself.

It is free, pre-approved, standardized, customizable residential building designs that the Provencal government has just provided that I bring forward as a topic of conversation.
“The digital designs are free to the public and can be used by builders, designers, and homeowners to build accessory dwelling units, duplexes, triplexes, quadplexes, and townhomes…Increased standardization and the component-based approach enable further efficiencies in the building and permitting process…Local governments can also choose to fast track approval of the designs to expedite permitting and development.” -Like the City of Quesnel did a year or so ago.

Max
Max
January 12, 2025 4:40 pm

Arrow

Prefab houses have been available since I have been alive. People don’t like them and the resale value sucks at best. You would probably even have a hard time arranging the financing to purchase the click together Lego block house.

Arrow
Arrow
January 12, 2025 4:24 pm

“The Province of British Columbia has commissioned standardized, customizable residential building designs and a companion catalogue for people building small-scale, multi-unit housing on lots previously zoned for single-family homes and duplexes.
A component-based approach that enables many potential configurations with interchangeable floor plans. Designs can be layered two or three storeys high, including options for garages and increased number of bedrooms. There are various roof shapes…”

Looks similar to working with Lego blocks. Does this format facilitate a productivity improvement over the stick-frame type of new neighbourhood development seen in the suburbs?
Surely the pre-approved & interchangeable designs would speed-up some parts of the process

https://www2.gov.bc.ca/assets/gov/farming-natural-resources-and-industry/construction-industry/building-codes-and-standards/guides/bc_std_des_catalogue_v1.pdf

Modular-Design
Bobby
Bobby
January 12, 2025 4:02 pm

487 Superior St was the house sold for 30% less, just look on housesigma, it’s the 1st home that popped up under sold homes

Mt. Tolmie Foothills
Mt. Tolmie Foothills
January 12, 2025 1:54 pm

Predictions for 2025:

sales: 7,200
sfd median: 1,200,000
condo median: 550,000
inventory: 2,400
interest rate: 3.00
Canada, Greenland, and the United State: amalgamate
Victoria, Saanich, et al: remain separate fiefdoms

EdgarAllanBro
EdgarAllanBro
January 12, 2025 12:15 pm

I would assume it’s 487 Superior that Marko is referring to

VicREanalyst
VicREanalyst
January 12, 2025 11:26 am

Only took an 8% haircut and purchase May 2022

Which one is it?

Marko Juras
January 12, 2025 11:12 am

4015 Loyola

Only took an 8% haircut and purchase May 2022.

VicREanalyst
VicREanalyst
January 12, 2025 10:11 am

One just resold for approx 10% more than June 2022 purchase price and one resold yesterday for approx 30% less than June 2022 purchase price.

3123 cedar Hill is the one that sold for more and 4015 Loyola the one that sold for less?

VicREanalyst
VicREanalyst
January 12, 2025 10:03 am

Are realtors still charging 6 and 3 these days?
6% on the first 100k and 3% on the balance?
Or am I way behind?

Everything is negotiable, right now on the buying side you can negotiate 1/3 commission back if buying a 1M plus house with most realtors in town. You can probably do 1/2 back with some desperate ones.

VicREanalyst
VicREanalyst
January 12, 2025 10:00 am

…..

Frank
Frank
January 12, 2025 9:55 am

The government will fast track any doctors and nurses that want to come to Canada from the U.S. Their credentials are recognized here and can start work immediately. We do have a health care crisis. They won’t help the housing crisis. I don’t think many of them want to move to China, India, Africa or North Korea. The water shortage in the southwest could last hundreds of years.

Max
Max
January 12, 2025 9:47 am

theres an old saying that if u dont have enough debt your not trying hard enough
I beg to differ.

I don’t think he means get up to your eyeballs in debt. If your getting close to paying off the house its good to add a bit more debt on and say maintain an LTV of 10% or less. This gives you access to cheap and easy credit with the financial institution.

Umm.. really?
Umm.. really?
January 11, 2025 9:48 pm

Developer’s debt woes worsen as more Metro Vancouver condo projects face insolvency

https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/thind-properties-eclipse-cra-millions-1.7427394

Peter
Peter
January 11, 2025 9:46 pm

theres an old saying that if u dont have enough debt your not trying hard enough

I beg to differ.

We are entering a period of asset inflation again imo

You’re probably right, and TBH it’s what’s paid off for us most of all over the years (decades). But, this asset inflation has gotten out of hand & is leaving younger generation(s) behind to the point where they’re no longer able to afford what “we” of a certain generation considered as basic “rights”. Like, the right to have a real, single-family house in a decent neighbourhood. I don’t mean Oak Bay or core or whatever, just a house in a decent hood. Ok I get it, we can and probably all will become like Croatia. I just don’t think it had to be that way.

Don’t ask me my solution, I’m not a politician…

Patrick
Patrick
January 11, 2025 8:06 pm

Of interest, Greater Victoria has the highest % of residents born in the U.S. among all 41 metro areas in Canada. It is 9,170 people and 2.4% of our population. Roughly 1/40 of our Victorians were born in USA. That’s more than the number of greater Victorians born in Quebec (2.2%). And not that far from the numbers of Victorians born in Manitoba (2.9%)

https://victoriabuzz.com/2022/11/over-half-of-greater-victorias-population-isnt-actually-from-bc-statistics-canada/?utm_source=chatgpt.com

IMG_0674
Frank
Frank
January 11, 2025 8:04 pm

Plus our government is kissing Trump’s ass. He’d love to see Californians leave the country.

totoro
totoro
January 11, 2025 5:57 pm

I don’t think they want to restrict immigration of highly skilled and educated U.S. citizens.

There are already paths for highly skilled and educated younger U.S. and other citizens. It is called the Federal Skilled Worker Program through the express entry program. We don’t get many of these applications from American citizens due to very high relative taxes/housing costs and much lower wages here in Canada – makes little sense for many professionals despite the gun control and political differences. We get more applicants from the U.S. from foreign workers on US visas who are applying to Canada.

Max
Max
January 11, 2025 3:48 pm

Maybe Croatia has an abundant supply.

I’m pretty sure its just reinforced mud at best. With 3″ party walls.

Frank
Frank
January 11, 2025 3:43 pm

You need the right type sand to make concrete. I’ve heard it’s in short supply here. Maybe Croatia has an abundant supply.

Max
Max
January 11, 2025 3:33 pm

I don’t think they want to restrict immigration of highly skilled and educated U.S. citizens.

Especially since they are right next door. You would think that they would be the first on the list.

Frank
Frank
January 11, 2025 3:25 pm

Like the Ukrainian situation, the government can change the rules to meet special circumstances. I don’t think they want to restrict immigration of highly skilled and educated U.S. citizens.

Patrick
Patrick
January 11, 2025 1:57 pm

>>> Interesting re fires as we have non-stop fires in Croatia all summer long, but typically little property damage. We had a huge wildfire come through our village 10 years ago and don’t remember a single house burning down. Mostly people had to replace windows the were the last row of homes in the village.

And yet, more people (per capita) die in Croatia from fires than Canada.
https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/fire-death-rates?tab=chart&time=1991..latest&country=HRV~CAN

IMG_2252
Max
Max
January 11, 2025 1:45 pm

Are realtors still charging 6 and 3 these days?
6% on the first 100k and 3% on the balance?
Or am I way behind?

Marko Juras
January 11, 2025 1:31 pm

Two houses in the COV sold within a week of each other in June 2022. One just resold for approx 10% more than June 2022 purchase price and one resold yesterday for approx 30% less than June 2022 purchase price.

Nither has significant upgrades from what I can see in photos.

Dad
Dad
January 11, 2025 1:02 pm

I think you’ll see a slight increase in Americans moving to Canada to get away from the rotten political culture in the US. But not enough to make a tangible difference in real estate markets.

Too many wildcards out there right now. If Trump goes ahead with blanket tariffs, and it increasingly sounds like he will, and Canada retaliates forcefully, we’ll see another wave of inflation. Presumably the BoC will have to keep rates elevated.

Recession + unemployment + elevated rates doesn’t bode well for any real estate market in Canada.

Max
Max
January 11, 2025 12:58 pm

Marko Juras

Croatia is not Canada. You seem to have a real hate on towards Canada. Why is that? You seem to think its normal to raise a couple kids in concrete towers and not have any pets because they cost 2k per year to feed.

Max
Max
January 11, 2025 12:53 pm

No they can’t. Since at least 2013, Canada has not accepted any asylum claims from the US.

What about other Countries? Do we accept their asylum claims?

totoro
totoro
January 11, 2025 12:47 pm

They can declare refugee status and stay here for years.

No they can’t. Since at least 2013, Canada has not accepted any asylum claims from the US.
https://www.irb-cisr.gc.ca/en/statistics/protection/Pages/index.aspx

Marko Juras
January 11, 2025 12:46 pm

Typically missing middle project in Croatia, a ton of concrete including balcony dividers -> https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AS1kyIDE80M

Marko Juras
January 11, 2025 12:43 pm

Interesting re fires as we have non-stop fires in Croatia all summer long, but typically little property damage. We had a huge wildfire come through our village 10 years ago and don’t remember a single house burning down. Mostly people had to replace windows the were the last row of homes in the village.

That being said everything in Croatia from houses to townhomes to condos are built out of concrete including partition walls in condos are also concrete. Wonder how large of a contributor to property damage and spread stick-frame construction is versus concrete?

totoro
totoro
January 11, 2025 12:23 pm

It is not easy for Americans to immigrate from the US to Canada. At all. And it just got harder. There is no retiree class visa like there is in many places in the world.

Working age US citizens will pay way more for cost of living than in many areas of the US and gain a way lower salary and pay way more taxes. There are many nice areas of the US that are at low risk of natural disasters. Seattle has many beautiful areas, as does Portland – especially outlying areas. Colorado has become a popular relocation destination for Californians looking for lifestyle, or Texas for lower taxation.

We have Canadian friends in Seattle. They are never coming back. Their healthcare coverage is way better and they can comfortably afford the premiums. Retired now, but their wage was double what they’d get here while working. They live in a nice house in a great area with low crime and now spend winters in Palm Springs.

That said, many Canadians who work in the US do end up back in Canada. Their US funds go further and there is no barrier to return.

thurston
thurston
January 11, 2025 12:20 pm

peter. trump said a few days ago he wants lower inflation and lower rates hmm

thurston
thurston
January 11, 2025 12:18 pm

max, good stuff , theres an old saying that if u dont have enough debt your not trying hard enough . folks that have little or no debt probaly dont have much in assets. We are entering a period of asset inflation again imo. Someone here said i should walk the talk and i have bought 2 properties in the last 2 years but they are commercial

Peter
Peter
January 11, 2025 12:15 pm

As I understand it, variable rates are influenced by BoC rates and fixed rate mortgages are influenced by 5-year bond yields.
Wishful thinking may influence BoC announcements, but not the bond market

Fair enough. I wasn’t speaking to the bond market, nor for that matter variable rates or even fixed rate mortgages. Just responding to the discussion on BOC rates, which I see continuing to trend down. Hey it’s January; good time for predictions.

Max
Max
January 11, 2025 11:50 am

Aren’t you and thursty banking on rate cuts?

I’m almost done paying this house off. The only reason I still have a mortgage is because I leveraged it for a 100k for the garden suite and some other household related things that needed attention. One more 5 year fixed and I’m done.

Without pulling out graphs and charts, I’d say I paid 5-6% on average for 5 year fixed rates over the course of that time. I might even go variable when I renew, whatever is cheaper. If I can get 3.25-3.50% for a five year fixed come late October…I’m all over it.

If I do get a 5 year fixed in that range, since I’ll have the room, I’m going to leverage another 50k to the principle.
I want a brand new 30 year roof installed, automated driveway gates, and a few other minor things around the house that are kind of pissing me off.

VicREanalyst
VicREanalyst
January 11, 2025 11:49 am

Why are you living in Victoria when you can live like a king in rural Croatia?

Even if people who who reside in LA plan to pack up and move to Canada don’t you think maybe they try Vancouver first. Jesus Christ, just stfu and stop posting.

Marko is living in Victoria because he grew up here and I imagine have many ties here both personal and business.

VicREanalyst
VicREanalyst
January 11, 2025 11:45 am

Add to that many of them can work remotely in any country and get paid in U.S. dollars. I

LMAO, RTO is the theme for all workers in 2025 and in the instances you can work remotely there are usually restrictions on what that entails (e.g. reside within a certain distance to the office.). Seriously just give it a rest, you have zero clue on what you are talking.

VicREanalyst
VicREanalyst
January 11, 2025 11:41 am

If people are banking on rate cuts…Sucks to be them.

Aren’t you and thursty banking on rate cuts?

Marko Juras
January 11, 2025 11:32 am

There is also the 40% exchange rate advantage,

There is also the foreign buyer ban for next two years at least.

Thursty
January 11, 2025 11:27 am

Not seeing what is so scary about trump , I’m expecting the next 4 years will be good for the economy . Folks that are moving about because of trump probaly have too active imagination

Frank
Frank
January 11, 2025 11:02 am

Marko- Have you been to Seattle or Portland? I haven’t but hear they are crime cesspools. There is also the 40% exchange rate advantage, healthcare (as bad as it is), the Trump factor that was already in play. Add to that many of them can work remotely in any country and get paid in U.S. dollars. I didn’t say everyone is going to rush to the Island, but a few hundred (out of 12 million) could have enough impact to spur a heated market. Why are you living in Victoria when you can live like a king in rural Croatia?

Arrow
Arrow
January 11, 2025 10:50 am

Rate cuts will continue

As I understand it, variable rates are influenced by BoC rates and fixed rate mortgages are influenced by 5-year bond yields.
Wishful thinking may influence BoC announcements, but not the bond market.

Canadian-5-year-bond-yield
Westerly
Westerly
January 11, 2025 10:35 am

We met a gay couple about a year ago who were emigrating from their home state to Europe on fears of Trump re-election. No idea the actual risk or their personal situation but it was a bit of an eye-opener.

Introvert
Introvert
January 11, 2025 10:11 am

Take it with a grain of salt, but Jason Binab told CHEK News that he’s getting “lots of phone calls from people south of the border who want to move back home” now that Trump is back in office.

Max
Max
January 11, 2025 8:49 am

Rate cuts will continue.

Well, that’s great too. I’m up for renewal October 29/2025.

Thursty
January 11, 2025 8:39 am

Yep I agree they will continue , good for real estate and good for exports. I think Canada is well positioned to take off again

Peter
Peter
January 11, 2025 8:37 am

Rate cuts will continue.

Max
Max
January 11, 2025 8:35 am

If BOC pauses I think spring market could be a challenging one.

If people are banking on rate cuts…Sucks to be them.

Marko Juras
January 11, 2025 8:17 am

U.S. job growth surged and unemployment fell last month, an unexpected show of strength that may prove costly to homebuyers and businesses who were counting on sharply lower interest rates to lower the cost of buying everything from refrigerators to homes.

If BOC pauses I think spring market could be a challenging one. I was counting on more BOC cuts to counteract all the other headwinds.

VicREanalyst
VicREanalyst
January 11, 2025 7:59 am

Why would people leave the country when they can just move to Seattle or elsewhere in Washington State?

Because that would take common sense.

Marko Juras
January 11, 2025 7:50 am

Why would people leave the country when they can just move to Seattle or elsewhere in Washington State?

Peter
Peter
January 11, 2025 7:45 am

I excluded any risky locations using the CMS Content map VicRE linked. We’re now living in a solid one story home smack-dab in the middle of a grey area (low hazard, low amplification)

And that is obviously a very valid approach. For myself, as long as I’m aware of the risks and rewards, I’m ok with risk. We had a geotech survey done on our slope before buying, but realizing nevertheless that we’re in a high-risk zone, the trade-offs are worth it for us.

Frank
Frank
January 10, 2025 7:34 pm

Top realtor from L.A. on CNN stated that he is currently paying $100,000 a year for insurance, and expects to pay $400,000 next year. Californians with mortgages and no insurance might look to leave the country. They can declare refugee status and stay here for years. L.A.’s population is equivalent to the 4 western provinces. Even an exodus of less than 1% would have an impact.
The snowfall comparison was beyond ignorant.

Umm.. really?
Umm.. really?
January 10, 2025 7:22 pm

U.S. job growth surged and unemployment fell last month, an unexpected show of strength that may prove costly to homebuyers and businesses who were counting on sharply lower interest rates to lower the cost of buying everything from refrigerators to homes.

https://apnews.com/article/jobs-unemployment-economy-federal-reserve-wages-398073325c467fb2c676042854f6309b

I-am-Groot
I-am-Groot
January 10, 2025 6:29 pm

How so short some people’s memories can be.

https://globalnews.ca/news/10641354/victoria-grass-fire-wildfire-risk/

caveat emptor
caveat emptor
January 10, 2025 3:42 pm

I think Victoria is relatively well placed re. fire and flood risk

Agree for core Victoria. Highlands seems like a wildfire disaster waiting to happen. Albeit the impacts will be modest overall because of the low population.

Arrow
Arrow
January 10, 2025 3:34 pm

maps?

Yep, from drawing road & block boundaries at 16 to pioneering highway cut-lines at 65, I spent a lot of time with maps. Now that is one part of the economy where there have been a lot of productivity improvements…less time & more accuracy (although those gains are diminished by the inefficiency of the workers building the thing).
I even have some on my walls; the large 1953 Fraser River Watershed showing Sockeye Spawning Areas is my favourite.

caveat emptor
caveat emptor
January 10, 2025 3:12 pm

The snowstorm in Texas will cause the prices on the Island to increase by 33.33%

Tropical cyclone lining up to hit Mozambique next week. Good for a couple percent increase in Vic?

VicREanalyst
VicREanalyst
January 10, 2025 3:08 pm

I didn’t spend my whole life working with maps to miss that layer and move out of the fire and into a frying pan.

Working with maps?

Arrow
Arrow
January 10, 2025 2:21 pm

Stupid, uninformed

Not being either of those, and knowing what part of town I wanted to move to, I excluded any risky locations using the CMS Content map VicRE linked. We’re now living in a solid one story home smack-dab in the middle of a grey area (low hazard, low amplification).
I didn’t spend my whole life working with maps to miss that layer and move out of the fire and into a frying pan.

Frank
Frank
January 10, 2025 1:26 pm

I took possession of my first investment property in May 1989 (before some of you nitwits were born). Paid $122,000 for a SFH in Cloverdale.. One year mortgage was 12.25%. In June an event on the other side of the world occurred known as the Tiananmen Square massacre and prices spiked for the same house $50,000 and never returned to the $120,000 level. Events around the globe can have a serious impact on real estate prices. California is a 2 day drive away. Again, lots of Canadians live in California. This is the start of an eco-migration. Climate change and a lack of water are huge motivating factors. The people that lost their homes, neighborhoods, schools, places of employment, need a place to live now, not 3 years from now.

VicREanalyst
VicREanalyst
January 10, 2025 1:10 pm

I think Victoria is relatively well placed re. fire and flood risk. Earthquakes not so much.

Go look at these before buying a house and deciding on earthquake insurance. https://cmscontent.nrs.gov.bc.ca/geoscience/PublicationCatalogue/GeoscienceMap/BCGS_GM2000-01.pdf
https://www.caee.ca/9CCEEpdf/School%20retrofit%20papers/Victoria_Hazard_Mapping_600dpi.pdf

VicREanalyst
VicREanalyst
January 10, 2025 1:09 pm

I don’t think US citizens will flock to the island

It’s not even related to citizenship, it’s a different market altogether and they are in no way substitutes for each other. It’s like saying people in Victoria will move to Haida Gwaii if there was an earthquake here. Stupid, uninformed and waste of time comments like that really diminishes the value of this forum.

Arrow
Arrow
January 10, 2025 12:37 pm

Canadians in high fire-risk areas are much more likely to relocate to lower risk areas

I moved to Victoria four months before a big fire destroyed 270 buildings back home. No smoke & no worries here (except for rising insurance premiums).

I-am-Groot
I-am-Groot
January 10, 2025 12:24 pm

The recent wildfires in California, particularly in Los Angeles, are likely to have a significant impact on the insurance market. The increasing frequency and severity of wildfires, exacerbated by climate change, have already led to higher premiums and reduced coverage options for homeowners in California.

As insurers face more claims and higher costs, they may pass these expenses onto consumers, resulting in even higher premiums. This trend could extend beyond California, affecting global insurance markets as insurers reassess risks and adjust their pricing models to account for the increased likelihood of natural disasters.

It’s a complex situation, but it’s clear that the financial toll of these wildfires will have far-reaching implications for the insurance industry.

totoro
totoro
January 10, 2025 11:57 am

Over time areas that are less prone to climate change events will probably increase at a greater rate. In the US it is already hard or impossible to get insurance in many areas because of this. Without insurance you can’t get a mortgage. This has already caused prices to drop in some areas in the US.

I don’t think US citizens will flock to the island for various reason including immigration difficulties, tax policies and human nature – people don’t switch countries easily and there are lots of places to move to within the US.

Canadians in high fire-risk areas are much more likely to relocate to lower risk areas though. In the US the realtor website already has fire and flood risk ratings for specific properties – probably going to be mandated here too one day. https://www.realtor.com/wildfire-risk/ Still, the awareness of how high the fire risk actually is in many BC communities remains low imo. People are essentially banking on the past as the best predictor, which it no longer is.

I think Victoria is relatively well placed re. fire and flood risk. Earthquakes not so much.

Thursty
January 10, 2025 11:28 am

Not seeing any relief on material prices and shite like LA is not helping. I’m floored by what stuff is costing when we get it shipped

Rodger
Rodger
January 10, 2025 11:01 am

The fires in L.A. could cause prices to increase 50% on the Island. Time will tell.

The snowstorm in Texas will cause the prices on the Island to increase by 33.33%. After all, we are the Hawaii of Canada. Combined with the fire in LA (50% increase), the prices on the Island will double 🙂

VicREanalyst
VicREanalyst
January 10, 2025 9:33 am

LMAO, just when I thought you can’t out do yourself and then here you are……

Frank
Frank
January 10, 2025 5:28 am

A war in Ukraine caused real estate to increase in Canada. There are a lot of Canadians living in California. I’ve been to L.A a few times, it’s a zoo. Considered moving there, had an Aunt living in Long Beach. Many residents did not have insurance, if they did their policies probably won’t cover replacement, especially given the strict codes and earthquake resistant building requirements necessary today. How can you rebuild without insurance, if it is available, I’ve heard of policies in the tens of thousands of dollars. The fires aren’t over yet and this is January. All it will take is an influx of a few hundred Californians shopping around and it could induce panic bidding again. Plus our real estate is 40% on sale for Americans.

penultimatepost
penultimatepost
January 9, 2025 10:38 pm

Any thoughts on plenum heaters vs heat pumps? I have an older gas furnace and a relatively new electric plenum heater(inherited from previous owner), and can switch between gas and electric just by pressing a button. But there’s no cooling function as with a heat pump. (We’re too new to the system to have sorted out which mode is cheaper yet.)

VicREanalyst
VicREanalyst
January 9, 2025 9:45 pm

The fires in L.A. could cause prices to increase 50% on the Island. Time will tell.

LMAO another wtf hot take from the internet armchair general. Have you ever been to LA?

Thurston
Thurston
January 9, 2025 9:32 pm

Frank , I was thinking the same thing , sales have been on a tear to start the year

Frank
Frank
January 9, 2025 8:53 pm

The fires in L.A. could cause prices to increase 50% on the Island. Time will tell.

caveat emptor
caveat emptor
January 9, 2025 4:54 pm

Huh? Baseboards do not function as dehumidifiers.

Yup that was a total bs statement, except in the general sense that anytime you heat air you lower the relative humidity. Nothing specifically to do with baseboards.

VicREanalyst
VicREanalyst
January 9, 2025 4:52 pm

He did call looking to for the follow on work and got agitated when I said he wasn’t going to be used for it.

Some contractors do not yet realize that the market has turned and getting bites on “go away pricing” is over.

Umm.. really?
Umm.. really?
January 9, 2025 4:14 pm

I end up doing many, many things myself that I don’t even want to do and would far rather pay someone for only because I don’t want to get ripped off. When I find service-providers who bill fairly, I’m their repeat customer indefinitely

I do most of it on my own, I use the contractors when I don’t want the permitting headache. The funny was, this particular trade came from a general contractor acquaintance because my usual go to was unavailable. So, I tested him with some smaller scale work. So, on 3k of work he ended up losing the next 30k to 40k in work from me and some friends that were waiting on a referral for the service that were likely to get about 30k x3 in work done. He did call looking to for the follow on work and got agitated when I said he wasn’t going to be used for it.

Max
Max
January 9, 2025 1:22 pm

GCs shove stuff down the throats of subs all the time

We’ve been using the same subs for years. We do grind, but its usually over time…Like hurry up, the inspection is booked for late afternoon and insulators are coming first thing tomorrow morning. Its called a push. If there were an unusual invoice, the book keeper would spot it right away and she would inform us and we would handle it.

Josh
Josh
January 9, 2025 12:50 pm

90 minutes? Jesus, I can get to downtown Vancouver from my house and be in the middle of a meeting in that time.

By far my fav commuting experience was going to my old workplace in Vancouver by float plane. Walked to the terminal, flew and walked to the office in ~40 mins. Most of my coworkers had longer commutes. Not exactly affordable but super neat. I hope electric VTOL aircraft bring down the cost of island travel but I have doubts.

Josh
Josh
January 9, 2025 12:39 pm

Baseboard heaters can create dry air

Huh? Baseboards do not function as dehumidifiers.

Frank
Frank
January 9, 2025 10:28 am

I knew a general contractor who told me his best year he grossed $3 million and ended up with a $40,000 loss.

VicREanalyst
VicREanalyst
January 9, 2025 10:24 am

I think it is worthwhile to repost this explanation on contractor’s costs.

Pretty much a bunch of b.s., will come down to the home owner’s understanding of the scope of work and market conditions. Contractors will work at breakeven or at a small loss (larger contractors) just to keep their crews intact when times are tough. Everything is negotiable if your business is important enough to the service provider (major GCs shove stuff down the throats of subs all the time), don’t be a dumb ass and believe the first thing you hear.

I-am-Groot
I-am-Groot
January 9, 2025 9:46 am

I think it is worthwhile to repost this explanation on contractor’s costs.

https://youtu.be/Vr5G1wBaBMg?si=ArIm_WvmjERr9N39

VicREanalyst
VicREanalyst
January 9, 2025 9:33 am

I find the biggest issue with being overcharged is the labour – if you get a fixed price quote.

Like I said before, contractor pricing is much more competitive now if they know you are getting multiple quotes. Also, we’ve been getting regular door knockers in our neighborhood now of various contractors trying to solicit business, this wasn’t the case couple of years ago.

Peter
Peter
January 9, 2025 8:30 am

People need to start pushing back on contractor theft more

I find the biggest issue with being overcharged is the labour – if you get a fixed price quote, of course it’s crazy high, and if you pay by the hour, suddenly you get a bill for “labour – 35 hours” for some relatively minor thing, and even with whatever monitoring you did along the way, it’s all kind of a black box.

I end up doing many, many things myself that I don’t even want to do and would far rather pay someone for only because I don’t want to get ripped off.

When I find service-providers who bill fairly, I’m their repeat customer indefinitely.

totoro
totoro
January 8, 2025 11:18 pm

Baseboard heaters can create dry air

Generally an advantage in Victoria. Our baseboards were in the home when we bought it – which is the case for most people I’d think. We did have one house that had been converted from oil to electric baseboard – but that is pretty rare and generally pre heat pump availability.

If you have and inefficient larger home and big hydro bills from baseboard heat it might make sense to get a heat pump – especially if you qualify for a grant.

If I have to pay 20k for a heat pump (plus annual service and any repairs) and get no grant based on the new income testing I’m never going to recoup this amount before I have to replace my heat pump if I’m only saving $500-$1000/year vs. current baseboard/gas fireplace/window ac use.

If hydro and natural gas rates rise then the numbers might shift.

Mt. Tolmie Foothills
Mt. Tolmie Foothills
January 8, 2025 9:45 pm

Baseboard heaters can be expensive to install

Chat GPT is out-to-lunch, baseboards are the cheapest to install.

Baseboard heaters can create dry air

Rarely an issue in Victoria

Umm.. really?
Umm.. really?
January 8, 2025 8:05 pm

I lived in a place once in unversity in Ontario and it had baseboards and I found it made our house too dry to the point where we needed a humidifier.

Dude, that wasn’t from the baseboard heaters, when you looked outside, was everything frozen with snow piled up? There’s something that happens to all that moisture in the air in places that have harsher winter climates.

Max
Max
January 8, 2025 6:41 pm

Bobby K. Baseboards are not without their cons

I burn way more cord wood than I use all the baseboard heaters in my house. I try to aim for when the winds are blowing towards the core with all its bike lanes that you traverse daily probably towing a trailer with three toddlers in the back and two leashed dogs on each handle bar.

Max
Max
January 8, 2025 6:37 pm

Bobby K. Our new heat pump cost around 5-6K

Says it all right there. I can assure you it won’t be the contractor that comes to pickup the pieces when it blows up. They will refer you to the manufacturer. Homeowner maintenance won’t fly.

Frank
Frank
January 8, 2025 6:31 pm

I don’t like any heaters that don’t have a fan to distribute the heat. I prefer the infrared quartz heaters. Pick them up second hand for $20-30. They use very little electricity. Use them in conjunction with high efficiency natural gas furnace.

Bobby K
Bobby K
January 8, 2025 6:07 pm

Baseboards are not without their cons

I lived in a place once in unversity in Ontario and it had baseboards and I found it made our house too dry to the point where we needed a humidifier.

Our new heat pump cost around 5-6K and came with a 7 year warranty on major parts, the contractor said homeowners can do most of the maintenance like cleaning filter and coils themselves and just get an inspection every few years for $140. Given how little they have to be used in our moderate climate the installer said to expect 15 -20 years or more lifespan. I think what convinced us was the ability to cool with AC and given climate change and clean energy and events like heat domes its nice to have even if we have the ocean near by. Our total electricity cost per month is averages under $100 in a 5 bedroom house on 2 levels with electric car, electric water heater, heat pump as we use time of day pricing, our car costs $3 to charge at night time.

From Chat GPT

Baseboard heating has several disadvantages, including:
Energy efficiency
Baseboard heating is less energy efficient than traditional HVAC systems, which can use up to 50% less electricity.
Cost
Baseboard heaters can be expensive to install, and they can increase your energy bill.
Space
Baseboard heaters take up space along the baseboards, limiting where you can put furniture.
Safety
Baseboard heaters get very hot, so they can be a hazard for children and pets.
Dry air
Baseboard heaters can create dry air, which can affect your health. You can use a humidifier to compensate.
Maintenance
Baseboard heaters need regular vacuuming to prevent dust buildup, which can make them work harder and use more energy.
Response time
Baseboard heaters have a slow response time.
Lack of cooling
Baseboard heaters don’t have cooling functionality.
Not ideal for large spaces
Baseboard heaters aren’t as cost-efficient for large spaces as forced air heating.
Temperature control
Hot water baseboard heaters aren’t precise systems, so it’s more reasonable to aim for a range rather than a specific temperature.
Lung inflammation
A 2009 study found that kids who live in homes with electric baseboard heaters showed higher rates of lung inflammation.

VicREanalyst
VicREanalyst
January 8, 2025 5:30 pm

People need to start pushing back on contractor theft more.

If you are getting trades blind and too lazy to get educated then you are asking to get ripped off, people need to expand their social network and have some “insider contacts” :).

VicREanalyst
VicREanalyst
January 8, 2025 3:40 pm

The house has baseboard heat in every room of the house.

That’s what I got, I think I will just keep the baseboard heating and pay the extra hydro with the wife’s upcoming spa set up in the back yard.

Umm.. really?
Umm.. really?
January 8, 2025 3:35 pm

speaking of the baseboard discussion –

People need to start pushing back on contractor theft more. It’s not gouging when they try to charge for work or products that was never done or put in, it’s theft. I had it recently where I got $890 materials bills for probably $75 (retail price) worth of ABS. I asked to see the materials list for the job. They weren’t able to provide it, but mystically amended the materials portion of the bill to $90. I don’t mind giving a retail rate on the parts and they pocket the difference with the supplier discount, but x10 above retail is fraud and theft.

Max
Max
January 8, 2025 3:31 pm

followed by flat house prices for 2021 to 2024.

This would be the point in time when house prices simply became out of reach for a lot of people.

I-am-Groot
I-am-Groot
January 8, 2025 3:20 pm

Is it a fact that houses always appreciate at a higher rate than condos?

No it isn’t. There are years when houses appreciate at a higher rate but then there are years when condos appreciate at a higher rate than houses.

There are noticeable trends when it comes to appreciation in houses and condos. From 2015 to 2017 houses appreciated more than condos but that was followed by flattish house prices from 2017 to 2019 while condo prices rose. A similar trend happened in 2019 to 2020 as house prices appreciated first, followed by flat house prices for 2021 to 2024. However condo prices increased from 2020 to 2022 while house prices remained flat.

Over the long term, at least the last decade, it has been a see saw back and forth when it comes to appreciation in house and condo prices in the Victoria Core. I suspect this is due to house owners seeing that their homes have increased choose to enter the condo investment market. The trend during the last decade being house prices rise first followed by a rise in condo prices.

Of course 2022 to 2024 had to be different as both house and condo prices have not shown any appreciation in the core. Which is likely due to lackluster investor sentiment. If your house hasn’t increased in value then you are less likely to buy a condominium as a rental in the next year or two. This is where the BC Assessments may play a role. If the assessments had increased substantially then home owners may have begun to consider buying a rental property. If the assessments stayed the same or declined slightly the home owner would be less likely to consider buying a rental property.

Of course the direction in rental rates, employment, interest, and vacancy rates are important too. In Victoria it seems that rental rates are softening and vacancy rates are increasing. But we still have low unemployment relative to most other cities in Canada.

Umm.. really?
Umm.. really?
January 8, 2025 3:20 pm

Here’s a useless way for the CRD to spend 33 million dollars on our behalf.

Maybe they will put a Jazz club on it.

Max
Max
January 8, 2025 2:33 pm

speaking of the baseboard discussion

The repair costs on heat pumps can reach levels that you’d be far better off buying a new heat pump altogether and replacing the refrigeration lines. My house has a 200amp square D electric heating house power panel. The house has baseboard heat in every room of the house. We only use baseboard heat in four rooms that are relatively small. It is however nice to know that I can turn all the baseboard heaters on at any given time if needed.

They are bullet proof.

ch
VicREanalyst
VicREanalyst
January 8, 2025 1:53 pm

Many even choose to live on Salt Spring Island and commute to Victoria every business day.

I know a few big law partners in Vancouver with that set up.

Marko Juras
January 8, 2025 1:39 pm
Max
Max
January 8, 2025 1:12 pm

Yes I agree, there are many people choosing to spend mid to high 7 figures to live out in North Saanich instead of in Uplands or 10 mile point.

Many even choose to live on Salt Spring Island and commute to Victoria every business day.

caveat emptor
caveat emptor
January 8, 2025 12:56 pm

Here’s a useless way for the CRD to spend 33 million dollars on our behalf.

https://www.crd.bc.ca/about/news/article/2025/01/07/crd-announces-agreement-to-purchase-kapoor-lumber-company-lands

I can somewhat understand desire to protect the watershed lands themselves. However these lands are not even within any of our current or future watersheds and are downstream of all the key reservoirs.

33 million dollars public money, 2000 hectares forever removed from productive use and/or public access (this area could instead continue to be used for forestry or it could be tacked onto Sooke Hills Park). And further costs down the road as the Water Board spends millions per year on patrolling and consultant studies on the areas they already control.

I know a little bit about this fiefdom. The folks that work in the watersheds have a pretty pleasant little gig. Spend the day driving your shiny white CRD truck around on old logging roads. Stop occasionally to take some measurements. On a busy day maybe you have to clear some deadfall off the road or paint one of the distinctive red gates with a new coat of red.

VicREanalyst
VicREanalyst
January 8, 2025 12:49 pm

But not everyone wants to live in the core. For example I have absolutely no desire to live in the core and it has nothing to do with money.

Yes I agree, there are many people choosing to spend mid to high 7 figures to live out in North Saanich instead of in Uplands or 10 mile point.

Max
Max
January 8, 2025 12:31 pm

Study out of Brazil showed that giving 20-25 year olds housing increased their chance of having children by 32%

The purpose of life is to procreate. That’s why they have a biological clock.

Max
Max
January 8, 2025 12:07 pm

Does it matter still? Everyone agrees that SFH is a better investment than townhouses and condos and core is better than outskirts.

Yes, I agree with you. A house in the core is defiantly a better investment than the outskirts. But not everyone wants to live in the core. For example I have absolutely no desire to live in the core and it has nothing to do with money.

totoro
totoro
January 8, 2025 11:24 am

Yeah, it matters if there is some logical reason for this that I am missing:

Not a given that your total return will be better.

VicREanalyst
VicREanalyst
January 8, 2025 11:10 am

Can you give me a plain language example of what you mean by yield?

Does it matter still? Everyone agrees that SFH is a better investment than townhouses and condos and core is better than outskirts.

totoro
totoro
January 8, 2025 9:54 am

I said total return, which incorporates both capital appreciation and yield. Not one versus the other.

Can you give me a plain language example of what you mean by yield? Are you talking about adding some imputed rental value to the calculation? Why? I can see this might be relevant to rent vs. buy but not to overall ROI on your primary residence. Just because you are buying shelter with it does not mean that you should add imputed rental value because you just are not paying this cost.

caveat emptor
caveat emptor
January 8, 2025 9:24 am

“Your not a man until you own some land… Trotsky”

Sounds more like Tolstoy….

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/How_Much_Land_Does_a_Man_Need%3F

patriotz
patriotz
January 8, 2025 6:26 am

overall net ROI on capital invested – not some weird additional yield metric

I said total return, which incorporates both capital appreciation and yield. Not one versus the other.

And I said right out that houses appreciate more than condos. So what exactly are you disagreeing with?

Frank
Frank
January 8, 2025 5:17 am

Finally got the prediction form submitted. It wouldn’t take my price predictions. Went through when I eliminated the commas in the numbers. The example shows commas.

Frank
Frank
January 8, 2025 3:22 am

Land is independence.

totoro
totoro
January 7, 2025 9:20 pm

No doubt you will get more capital appreciation because more of the value is in the land. Not a given that your total return will be better. That depends on both capital appreciation and yield (rental value relative to price).

Makes no sense. On a primary residence you need to compare overall net ROI on capital invested – not some weird additional yield metric.

Historically houses have appreciated faster than condos. Its a Leo approved fact. https://househuntvictoria.ca/2024/10/21/revisiting-holding/

Umm.. really?
Umm.. really?
January 7, 2025 7:44 pm

Or an ice axe.

Thursty
January 7, 2025 7:24 pm

Your not a man until you own some land… Trotsky

Frank
Frank
January 7, 2025 7:02 pm

One explanation for the obsession with SFHs: Land is power.

Mt. Tolmie Foothills
Mt. Tolmie Foothills
January 7, 2025 5:45 pm

I’ll never understand the North American obsession with SFHs.

An advantage of owning an SFD is you can do a lot of the maintenance yourself.
For example, you can do the regular servicing of your heat pump and save hundreds of dollars every year.

Umm.. really?
Umm.. really?
January 7, 2025 5:14 pm

link? I though these were commercial and very expensive.

Residential application video for the gas absorption heat pump

https://youtu.be/eX4i7Eb2rbE?feature=shared

Max
Max
January 7, 2025 3:41 pm

I have a masonry chimney attached to the side of my house that was originally built for two wood burning open fireplaces. One up and one directly below it on the lower level. When we bought the house the previous owner had installed two natural gas inserts with the flues running up the chimney.

Both my Wife and I don’t like the idea of natural gas in the house, so I turned off the gas at the meter and its been sitting like that since 1998. Since I already have power to both fireplaces for the fans, I would like to upgrade to high efficiency electric fireplaces.

Kind of like this…

ef
Umm.. really?
Umm.. really?
January 7, 2025 2:37 pm

And this can be your primary heat source?

Apparently yes, a new air handling unit with it fed by it.

Umm.. really?
Umm.. really?
January 7, 2025 1:59 pm

link? I though these were commercial and very expensive.

All the links on the residential systems are from the US. Advantage Heating has been doing it locally. So, I am going to get quoted and see where the cost lands and if it’s worth it.

Max
Max
January 7, 2025 1:45 pm

” Following the lead of other B.C. municipalities, such as Saanich and Victoria. Nanaimo bans natural gas as primary heat in new homes as of July 2024.”

“If we can move faster by a few years, we should do it,” she said. “When something is harmful to the public, whether it is speeding, driving under the influence, or polluting the atmosphere, it ceases to be a personal choice and becomes a public issue.”

https://vancouversun.com/news/local-news/nanaimo-bans-natural-gas-as-primary-heat-in-new-homes-as-of-july-2024

Sidekick
Sidekick
January 7, 2025 1:29 pm

gas absorption heat pump

link? I though these were commercial and very expensive.

Max
Max
January 7, 2025 1:17 pm

On heating side. Changing out the oil furnace this spring on the reno project. Looks like the gas absorption heat pump might be taking the lead as an option. It can do the heat, ac, and hot water. Apparently, it can also run as a generator during power outages. Also, I really don’t mind that it runs all the combustion exterior to the house.

And this can be your primary heat source?

Umm.. really?
Umm.. really?
January 7, 2025 12:49 pm

On heating side. Changing out the oil furnace this spring on the reno project. Looks like the gas absorption heat pump might be taking the lead as an option. It can do the heat, ac, and hot water. Apparently, it can also run as a generator during power outages. Also, I really don’t mind that it runs all the combustion outside the house.

patriotz
patriotz
January 7, 2025 12:49 pm

No doubt whatsoever, SFH is a better long term investment financially.

No doubt you will get more capital appreciation because more of the value is in the land. Not a given that your total return will be better. That depends on both capital appreciation and yield (rental value relative to price).

Marko Juras
January 7, 2025 12:43 pm

Why? Privacy, control of environment ie. no common spaces, noise, ability to add value, ability to house family when needed in a suite, pets, workshop access, private outdoor space with garden, no strata, extended family gatherings, and a greater rate of leveraged appreciation that is tax free.

No doubt whatsoever, SFH is a better long term investment financially.

I’ve never had noise issues living in condos but I’ve never lived in a wood-framed either. As far as common spaces I use it to my advantage. We have an awesome gym in my building no one uses so I essentially have a large private gym I pay 1/133th for.

Umm.. really?
Umm.. really?
January 7, 2025 12:42 pm

At that point you might as well just get a townhouse

Ya, when I was looking out towards Sooke and Sidney/Lands end during the pandemic, I would get confused responses when I would be looking at houses on about an acre : “well, that’s not what you have been looking at in the core” and my response “we the F would I move all the way out to one of these places to have less space than in the core”?

VicREanalyst
VicREanalyst
January 7, 2025 11:56 am

Thing is most people are commuting to their 3,500 sq/ft lot in Royal Bay/Westhills/Sooke/etc.

At that point you might as well just get a townhouse….. But then again that’s what lot of lots in Vancouver are around and they are still in demand so….

Marko Juras
January 7, 2025 11:54 am

FWIW, small high density SFH lots would not suit me either.

Thing is most people are commuting to their 3,500 sq/ft lot in Royal Bay/Westhills/Sooke/etc.

VicREanalyst
VicREanalyst
January 7, 2025 11:48 am

Just another political ploy or am I missing something? Maybe this works with homes charging electric vehicles?

That’s how they even it out, charge more for peak hours and reduce for the lowest usage hours. I don’t think it’s worth it unless you got 2 heavily used EVs.

Westerly
Westerly
January 7, 2025 11:25 am

Here’s another Hydro question: I was looking at the BC Hydro offer to reduce the rate from 11PM -7AM. The idea being that you can set your laundry / dishwasher etc to start after 11 at night and be finished by 7 am and you save 5 cents per KWH (or something like that). Not realizing the rules of the program we started turning what we could on after bedtime to run while we slept. Nice to have clean dishes in the am.

Found out though that: 1. you have to sign up for the program, and 2. they increase the charge from something like 4-10 PM by the same .05 / unit. Our kids have moved out and we would still use more hydro in the 4-10 PM than later in the night including if we used appliances later in the evening / am.

Just another political ploy or am I missing something? Maybe this works with homes charging electric vehicles?

totoro
totoro
January 7, 2025 11:24 am

never understand the North American obsession with SFHs

I’d prefer larger concrete built condo in the core to a house that required a commute. However, def prefer a house in the core to a condo as long as I’m able bodied.

Why? Privacy, control of environment ie. no common spaces, noise, ability to add value, ability to house family when needed in a suite, pets, workshop access, private outdoor space with garden, no strata, extended family gatherings, and a greater rate of leveraged appreciation that is tax free.

Westerly
Westerly
January 7, 2025 11:06 am

Re: obsession with SFHs… Same here, I’d have a hard time fitting my 22′ boat under a condominium. My spouse loves to entertain and I love gardening. Her value is inside, mine is outside. Win-win.

Yet Another Boomer
Yet Another Boomer
January 7, 2025 10:59 am

I’ll never understand the North American obsession with SFHs.

Not sure my metal lathe, CNC plasma cutter etc. would go over very well in a condo. Time spent in the garden would also be very different. Everybody has different interests. Condo lifestyle would suit me about half time. The other half not at all. FWIW, small high density SFH lots would not suit me either. Each to their own.

Marko Juras
January 7, 2025 10:49 am

Some are 45 mins, others are near 90 mins if it’s a “bad” day.

I’ll never understand the North American obsession with SFHs. I much prefer my condo which is pretty much the same value as a Sooke/Malahat average home and I get to spend that 45 to 90 min x 2 walking/running along the Songhees Walkway versus stuck in traffic.

caveat emptor
caveat emptor
January 7, 2025 10:48 am

too much hate for baseboards especially in newer homes that are relatively well insulated

with step 5 code probably be good enough to just push down your toaster once in a while (on top of the waste heat from your always on electronics)

caveat emptor
caveat emptor
January 7, 2025 10:45 am

If everyone was heating their homes with wood, it would be disastrous for particulate emissions

Yes. Wood burning makes great sense if you live rural. In communities it is only marginally acceptable because relatively few people do it. If it was widespread pollutant levels would quickly become unacceptable.

One modern wood stove particulate emissions is similar (order of magnitude) to a heavy duty diesel truck idling 24 hours/day which many would object to.

Most polluted communities in BC- all Interior valley communities where wood heating is prevalent – Vanderhoof, Valemount, Grand Forks, Quesnel, Houston….

https://www.canada.ca/en/health-canada/services/air-quality/indoor-air-contaminants/avoid-wood-smoke.html

#1 contributor to air quality mortality in Canada
https://publications.gc.ca/collections/collection_2023/sc-hc/H144-112-2022-eng.pdf

Marko Juras
January 7, 2025 10:39 am

As I’ve been saying for 15+ yrs on HHV, too much hate for baseboards especially in newer homes that are relatively well insulated. I go into houses with 40-50 year old baseboards and they still work. I find a lot of information put out in relation to efficency of heating systems does not include maintenance/realistic lifespan/availablity of parts of such systems in 15 to 30 years, etc.

If I was to service the air to water heatpump in my condo as per manufacturers recommendation with South Island Mechanical, RedBlue, Batallion or similar company the annual service cost would exceed my total yearly hydro bill (and most likely would exceed my total yearly hydro bill if I had baseboards instead).

caveat emptor
caveat emptor
January 7, 2025 10:20 am

4 days a week in the office for provincial employees.

I do see the province following the feds on this. However i doubt it will be across the board in 2025. Some organizations have already given up the space they’d need to implement that.

Would be a good way to downsize the ranks a bit though as a handful would leave to pursue other opportunities

SaanichAdam
SaanichAdam
January 7, 2025 10:14 am

Might be true VicRE, but I’ve got 10+ staff at my company who come from Sooke and up the Malahat. Some are 45 mins, others are near 90 mins if it’s a “bad” day.

VicREanalyst
VicREanalyst
January 7, 2025 9:53 am

As we move back to in-office and away from WFH, this will put MORE pressure on core properties as many will get sick of their 46-90 min commutes from the satellite communities, in my opinion.

90 minutes? Jesus, I can get to downtown Vancouver from my house and be in the middle of a meeting in that time.

VicREanalyst
VicREanalyst
January 7, 2025 9:50 am

Such as?

4 days a week in the office for provincial employees.

VicREanalyst
VicREanalyst
January 7, 2025 9:45 am

I wouldn’t shy away from BBs but would depend on the house age, layout (Up / down has to be more efficient than a large rancher with the same space) etc.

I do like the convenience and effectiveness of BB’s.

SaanichAdam
SaanichAdam
January 7, 2025 9:25 am

As we move back to in-office and away from WFH, this will put MORE pressure on core properties as many will get sick of their 46-90 min commutes from the satellite communities, in my opinion. Nothing is a bigger quality of life upgrade than living less then 15-20 mins walk, drive, or bike from work and essentials. It annoys me in the Westshore at the amount of congestion and you-must-drive everywhere. Younger people are willing to lower their vehicle costs and cortisol costs (lol) to be closer to amenities without stress. So, more price pressure on core properties if WFH is ending and, coupled with the fact that there might be lower net migration to Victoria, you might see much less appreciation, or only flat prices in Langford, Sooke etc.

Westerly
Westerly
January 7, 2025 9:22 am

“Is that including your tenants? That sounds pretty cheap”
Sort of, it was 1 person living there (MIL). Newer home and when we had it built we also put insulation in every wall downstairs (house was up / down) and in every floor. Was more of a noise reducer step but must have also helped with heating. Oh, gas HW as well which skews it a bit.

We could actually leave our heaters off much of the time as MIL would heat the lower enough that it kept the house warm. The BBs were turned off most of the summer, almost all of June – Oct where we would use the gas FP to supplement.

I wouldn’t shy away from BBs but would depend on the house age, layout (Up / down has to be more efficient than a large rancher with the same space) etc.

Umm.. really?
Umm.. really?
January 7, 2025 9:18 am

Such as?

The Feds moved to 3 days in office last September and will likely be going to 4 this upcoming September. A change in government will likely see it back to 5 in September this year. As for the province, they have still been hiring folks on the basis they are full time remote. So, I imagine provincial RTO will be an al a carte approach depending on the job requirements and not blanket like the feds.

rush4life
rush4life
January 7, 2025 9:05 am

Significant changes coming to wfh this year.

Such as?

VicREanalyst
VicREanalyst
January 7, 2025 9:05 am

4,000′ home with 2 bd suite and our bill was typically $200-$250 / month.

Is that including your tenants? That sounds pretty cheap.

Jp
Jp
January 7, 2025 8:40 am

Should compare the realtors predictions vs non realtors. In theory, the “professionals” would have more accurate predictions right?

Patrick
Patrick
January 7, 2025 8:20 am

For 2025…

Sales: 6700

Single Family Median (Q4): $1185000

Condo Median (Q4): $525000

December Inventory: 2500

Bank of Canada Rate: 3.0%

Westerly
Westerly
January 7, 2025 8:11 am

I don’t have the kwh’s available but we had base boards in our last home. We had a natural gas fire place (not used for primary heat) and kitchen stove. 4,000′ home with 2 bd suite and our bill was typically $200-$250 / month. When we had the house built we had timers installed on the electric BBs – game changer I think. This was a huge plus and we never missed not having a heat pump.

We have a HP now in a smaller house and it’s also nice – particularly the AC feature in summer. Next house will be a mix as we’ll also want solar.

VicREanalyst
VicREanalyst
January 7, 2025 7:53 am

We used an average of 15 kWh per day over the last 30 days as the gas fireplace heats the house adequately and this keeps us out of tier 2.

Ha I am at close to 100kwh/day. Wife does not feel safe with gas so that’s a no go for me. Contemplating heat pump but baseboard is so nice and flexible.

VicREanalyst
VicREanalyst
January 7, 2025 7:50 am

Significant changes coming to wfh this year.

Josh
Josh
January 7, 2025 6:33 am

For the same amount of energy, burning wood emits more CO2 than coal.

There’s other factors at play. I’m not sure why wood would be compared to coal without mentioning that coal is non-renewable while wood is renewable. The only CO2 emitted was absorbed while the tree grew. There’s also some amount of forestry that happens for wild fire mitigation. Prescribed burning can happen in wood stoves and it’s a win-win. Same goes for trees that died naturally (to some extent) or had to come down for property protection.

If everyone was heating their homes with wood, it would be disastrous for particulate emissions and couldn’t be done sustainably. That isn’t the case. Pointing the environmental shame finger at wood burners is barking up the wrong tree as long as crude oil is around. Pun intended.

Frank
Frank
January 7, 2025 6:12 am

Took the condo price, trying to get it to take SFH price.

Frank
Frank
January 7, 2025 6:08 am

The prediction form won’t take my price predictions. Took the sales, inventory and bank rate. Comes up “Must be above 0.”

Frank
Frank
January 7, 2025 3:01 am

The dense forests end up burning out of control anyway. Destroying some cities. Where have you been? The ash residue makes great fertilizer for a garden (to grow potatoes) as it contains minerals absorbed from the ground.
Forest fires are a natural process of rejuvenation, might as well get some heat out of it. Similar to natural gas that would just be burned off in the extraction of oil, something that will never end as long as humans inhabit the planet.

EdgarAllanBro
EdgarAllanBro
January 6, 2025 10:26 pm

https://househuntvictoria.ca/2025/01/06/2025-predictions/#comment-124023

I use about 38 kWh per day on average, even with my gas fireplace in use. However, the house could benefit from new windows and upgraded insulation, and since I’m located on the waterfront in a very windy area, my energy usage is probably higher than it should be.

I’m still considering whether to install a heat pump during renovations. I appreciate the low maintenance of the baseboard heaters, and I mainly want the heat pump for air conditioning without having to use ugly/bulky window or portable ACs, so it might not be worth the investment.

Screenshot-2025-01-06-221546
Umm.. really?
Umm.. really?
January 6, 2025 10:14 pm

Bobby is late for their Midnight Oil concert.

Bobby K
Bobby K
January 6, 2025 10:03 pm

Wood burning which is already highly regulated should be banned altogeather for health reasons for the general population and also for the homeowners own health.

From ChatGPT

Wood burning is bad for the environment:
Air pollution
Wood burning releases many pollutants into the air, including:
Fine particulate matter (PM2.5)
Volatile organic compounds (VOCs)
Carbon monoxide (CO)
Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs)
Nitrogen oxides (NO2)
Dioxins and furans
Chlorinated dioxins
Climate change
Wood burning releases carbon dioxide (CO2), a greenhouse gas that contributes to climate change. For the same amount of energy, burning wood emits more CO2 than coal.
Forest destruction
Cutting down trees to burn for energy destroys forests, damages ecosystems, and leads to biodiversity loss. Forests are important in the fight against climate change because they absorb CO2.
Indoor air pollution

Wood burning releases particle pollution into homes, which can have a negative impact on people’s health. A 2020 study found that during the time wood burners were lit, the level of harmful particles in homes was three times higher than when stoves were not being used.

Frank
Frank
January 6, 2025 8:56 pm

Max-Hauling your own firewood, growing your own potatoes, you should be on Survivor.

Sidekick
Sidekick
January 6, 2025 8:56 pm

Also heat pumps only work to an outside temperature of 5+ C

Not true. Lots of heat pumps are more efficient than baseboard at the coldest temperatures we see here (-10).

I have a Sanden CO2 hot water heat pump

Pretty hard to make a $ use case when only used for domestic hot water. They support being a combi heat source up to 12k btu. I just looked up my old place and the Sanden gen3 used 1359kWh for the entire year (domestic HW and whole home heat).

Air-to-water heat pumps are ramping up in North America (been in Europe for a while), and there are some good looking units out there. Downside is lack of easy cooling. I put an Arctic 60k btu unit in for the inlaws and it seems ok.

It’s pretty hard to argue against baseboards – they’re cheap, reliable, low-ish embodied energy and renewable. I’m leaning towards decent mini-splits for the new place. Maybe one per floor. I think cooling will be a thing here in the next 10-20 years.

totoro
totoro
January 6, 2025 8:43 pm

My prediction for 2025 is lots more spring inventory – I think a lot of sellers have been waiting to list – and flattish prices with some good deals in the luxury sfh market over 3 million and on condos.

I think our dollar is going to drop more and this is likely to have negative knock on effects on our economy and consumer confidence.

However, it is really hard to find an attractive newer SFH in the core these days at a price under 2.5 million. I see that 1800 Chandler in Gonzales sold for $2,165,000 which is 66k over ask and 124k over assessed. I’d expect that trend to continue for SFHs that don’t need renos, are well located in the core, without obvious defects, and are under 3 million.

Westerly
Westerly
January 6, 2025 8:43 pm

Looks like the Capital Gains Tax 50% to 66% is still somewhat up in the air:
https://financialpost.com/personal-finance/taxes/prorogation-kills-capital-gains-tax-changes

Hoping for no change and pretty sure PP was in that camp as well.

totoro
totoro
January 6, 2025 7:55 pm

Baseboards are no maintenance and last forever – we have never had to service or replace ours. We have baseboards with a gas fireplace, gas dryer and gas water heater. Our home is 2003 built and 1400 square feet.

We used an average of 15 kWh per day over the last 30 days as the gas fireplace heats the house adequately and this keeps us out of tier 2. The fireplace is on a thermostat and has worked reliably for the last 12 years with just an annual cleaning. We keep the thermostat at 19 overnight or when out in the day and 22/23 when home – I know it is higher than some set it but we like it warmer and we face south so get some passive solar heating.

Our hydro bill is projected to be $136 for the last 60 days ($67/month). However our natural gas bill for December was $108.89 – $15.00 was the market price of gas and the rest was taxes/transport.

We’ve considered a heat pump at various times, but the math doesn’t work when you are paying less than $200 a month for hydro/fortis in the coldest part of winter despite all the added taxes on the natural gas. In the summer we do use window AC if it gets too hot upstairs but we still generally don’t go over 15 kWh per day. Our total fortis/hydro charges in spring/summer are about $100/month.

Max
Max
January 6, 2025 7:18 pm

Rarely burn more than half a cord of wood.

We burn 3 cords of Douglas fir per year. We head north of Lantzville and hit a Rez. I tow a 14′ trailer and have a truck box of 4’x 8′. They load it with a front end loader. 3 cords for $550 cash and carry, I’m in and out of there in less than 10 minuets. Its not seasoned or ready to burn, but its split and good to go. I just dry dry it out in my garage for the following burning season.

Yet Another Boomer
Yet Another Boomer
January 6, 2025 5:54 pm

who’s on baseboard heating here with SFH? How many kwh do you use on average per day?

I can’t give you a per day because I don’t track it by day and it varies a lot based outside temperature but I can give you exactly how much per heating season. I am on one of the original E-Plus accounts with a separate meter for heating only. Prior to 21/22 is using a 15 Kwh electric furnace plus a couple of baseboards in upstairs bedrooms and a small heater in a detached garage (shop). In 2021/22 we converted the electric furnace back to wall mounted electric panel heaters because we don’t like the noise and moving air of a forced air furnace. There are other variations with different numbers of people in the house but this will give you a ball park. This is for a 1905 (insulated walls and double pane wood windows) 1800 square foot 1 1/2 story house plus an unfinished full size basement (not included in the 1800) We are home all day and leave the heat on from 8:00 am to 11:30 pm (68 to 70 degrees). There is a fireplace with wood stove that we use for ambiance in the evening once or twice a week. Rarely burn more than half a cord of wood. Most of the wood is scraps off the table saw and tree prunings along with the occasional pallet or tree round picked up off the side of the street.

2017/18 10185 KwHr
2018/19 8729 KwHr
2019/20 9004 KwHr
2020/21 9843 KwHr
2021/22 9438 KwHr
2022/23 8793 KwHr

I used to be a big fan of heat pumps but I am swinging towards the camp that says the business case is not really there for me. What I have now has no servicing, long life, reliable, silent, pretty safe compared to the alternatives, no GHG freon and not outrageously expensive. I have a Sanden CO2 hot water heat pump that uses about 1/3 the electricity of an electric HW tank but unless it lasts a long time you probably couldn’t make a business case at current electricity rates. Mine is the older model without the smarts to circulate HW during real cold snaps so I have the compressor compartment insulated with styrofoam and a 100W light bulb inside but I have to worry about turning it on. So far no freezing issues (other than a pipe in the wall that was on the wrong side of the insulation!) Solar panels on the garage would probably be a better investment than more heat pumps.

Max
Max
January 6, 2025 3:55 pm

who’s on baseboard heating here with SFH? How many kwh do you use on average per day?

We are. We also have the biggest wood stove you’re allowed right in the center of the house. It was supplied and installed by pacific energy, WETT compliant. I took out a permit and it was inspected by both a Langford fire Marshall and a Langford Building Inspector. This was a requirement for my house insurance.

From my reading baseboard wins over heat pumps. They never have to be replaced or serviced (ever). They just always work. We use them in the two kids rooms and the baths. I don’t exactly know how many kwh we use, but its reasonable. I spend around $900 per year to heat a 2600 sq/ft house per season with a combination of both fir cord wood and baseboard heat. Add on another $300 per year for the water heater, dryer, and the range. add on another $300-$400 in overruns for a family of four. I’d say I pay around $1500-$1800 to energize the house for a year.

Marko did a write up on how baseboard heat compared to a heat pump over the long term. Baseboards were suggested due to the annual cost of servicing the heat pump, cost to operate the heat pump, and the cost of the heat pump replacement in ten years (when there will be no more grants available). Also heat pumps only work to an outside temperature of 5+ C, baseboard heaters work regardless of the outside temperature.

Thursty
January 6, 2025 3:50 pm

Can’t help, I’ve taken them out in the past as they are bloody expensive to run . I’m always putting in gas

VicREanalyst
VicREanalyst
January 6, 2025 2:11 pm

who’s on baseboard heating here with SFH? How many kwh do you use on average per day?

I-am-Groot
I-am-Groot
January 6, 2025 1:31 pm

Well the Soy Boy is gone and that might force PP to put forward his policies to reduce government, solve the housing problem, immigration, drug use, homelessness, tariffs, etc. Now we just have to get rid of the wimp.

He’s going to need a bigger T Shirt.

VicREanalyst
VicREanalyst
January 6, 2025 12:49 pm

specifically on the Westshore will be facing fairly large increases in mortgage payments.

Why the westshore? Do those owners typically have bigger mortgage balances? If someone bought around a million dollar home and put 20% down then they are carrying ~850k mortgage which is like around 4k a month given 4% fixed rates at 30 year amort. They would have been stress tested at more than that so it should be fine unless they did something stupid afterwards.

Marko Juras
January 6, 2025 12:39 pm

However in construction and supporting industries it should be busy with everyone pushing projects through before new building codes hit in the spring.

Fyi, small detail….my apartment building in Colwood I was able to get a code extension until 2027.

Projects that are subject to development permit applications2 have a new option to
extend the application of the seismic and adaptable dwelling unit requirements in the
BC Building Code 2018 provided the following criteria are met:
Drawings must:
• contain information on the number of dwelling units, OR information on the
dimensions of dwelling units, OR information on the dimensions of structural
components or assemblies,
• be prepared by, or prepared under the supervision of, a registered professional3
or a registrant of the Applied Science Technologists & Technicians of BC, AND
• have been submitted in a form satisfactory to a local authority as part of a
development permit application before March 8, 2024.
If these three criteria are met, then seismic and adaptable dwelling unit requirements
in the BC Building Code 2018 apply to the project; HOWEVER, a building permit for the
project must be applied for before March 8, 2027, AND work must continue to
completion without interruption, other than work stoppages considered
reasonable to industry. If these three criteria are met but the building permit is
applied for on or after March 8, 2027, then the seismic and adaptable dwelling unit
requirements in the BC Building Code 2024 apply to the project.

Max
Max
January 6, 2025 11:40 am

I believe some of the 4 million Canadian citizens living in other countries will return to escape the conflicts around the world.

Well that would be more than welcome with open arms, hopefully some are doctors.

Max
Max
January 6, 2025 11:36 am

Trudeau is resigning when new liberal leader is chosen.

He said he “Intends” to resign.

” Trudeau said that he intends to resign as both Liberal leader, and prime minister, once his party “selects its next leader through a robust, nationwide, competitive process.”

In·tend
verb
3rd person present: intends
have (a course of action) as one’s purpose or objective; plan.

Prorogue is a technical way of saying “put off” or “delay.”

https://www.ctvnews.ca/politics/canadians-deserve-a-real-choice-justin-trudeau-resigning-prorogues-parliament-1.7165612

Thursty
January 6, 2025 10:59 am

Frank, a good take on it , there is a ton of Canadians with huge wealth and sfh home prices in Vic really aren’t that expensive. Sell your place in Toronto or Van and u have more than enough to come live in oak bay

Max
Max
January 6, 2025 10:23 am

06/01/2025 09:59:51/ Max/ 6600 / 1150000 /495000/ 2750 / 2.75

Copied and time stamped from the spreadsheet.

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1cLXTLuCTvKbqa0parNrGmrUgH0RfgiCqkHLR-nH1yM0/edit?gid=631119299#gid=631119299

Frank
Frank
January 6, 2025 10:20 am

Immigration levels will be cut but I believe some of the 4 million Canadian citizens living in other countries will return to escape the conflicts around the world. That would bode well for Canada as many of them are highly educated. With the new Trump administration returning, more Americans will also look north. Especially Californians targeting B.C. So I wouldn’t expect B.C. prices to go down, probably tick up 5-10%. It’s only getting more expensive to build and solid existing homes with a fair sized lot will be in high demand. I don’t think the economy will have much effect as you have to be very well off to even consider moving to B.C. In the last 15 years the wealthy enjoyed a doubling or tripling of their net worth.

Frank
Frank
January 6, 2025 9:57 am

BNN-Trudeau is resigning when new liberal leader is chosen. Hopefully by 4:00pm. Greenland would be a perfect place for his exile.

Marko Juras
January 6, 2025 9:45 am

One thing I’ll add is it is important to keep an open mind as information comes in during the course of the year.

My 2024 predictions were very accurate with the exception of the BoC @ 4.5%; however, as the data starting coming in spring of 2024 I had made my mind up that I was going variable on my mortgage as based on what I was seeing in the spring I figured large BoC cuts were coming.

Marko Juras
January 6, 2025 9:42 am

Sales: 7200
Single family Q4 2025 median: $1,130,000
Condo Q4 2025 median: $530,000
Inventory: 2450
Bank of Canada rate: 2.0%

In my humble, non-expert non-economist opinion the economy is in much worse shape than we think and I think this will result in the overnight lending rate dropping down to 2.0% and a difficult real estate market at the same time. The 5 year fixed rates likely won’t change much during 2025 so I don’t think the drop in the BoC overnight lending rate will prop up the market too much and will be counterbalanced by the difficult economy.

Regarding the single family pricing I do agree with you that upzoning will prop up land prices/lower end in the core; however, a bit of an oddball thought I have is with 25% of CND mortgages renewing in 2025 even with rates coming down many owners, specifically on the Westshore will be facing fairly large increases in mortgage payments. Therefore, if the sale mix shifts a bit to more homes selling on the Westshore versus core it could impact the median even if prices don’t change much.

My logic behind higher sales but ever so slightly lower prices (basically flat) is the higher sales will be offset by more inventory. I have a feeling more listings will come to market this spring than what is currently anticipated.

caveat emptor
caveat emptor
January 6, 2025 9:16 am

For 2025 no real idea where home prices are going. Flattish to slightly up I’d guess.
Predictions:
Barrister resurfaces with a new identity
Max wins the comments in the volume category
Vic RE Analyst wins in the snark category.

And in a surprise move Trump gives Canada to Denmark in exchange for Greenland.

Arrow
Arrow
January 6, 2025 9:15 am

asked Gov. Gen. Mary Simon to prorogue Parliament until March 24, and she granted the request.

Adrift & rudderless:
No sitting Provincial Legislature between May 17, 2024 and February 18, 2025;
No sitting Federal Parliament between December 18 2024 and March 24 2025. Then a non confidence motion and (likely) a 36-50 day election period, then an election, then all sorts of Parliamentary ritual before the sitting of the house begins.
Hopefully they get to work before taking the summer break.